Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Naga A.

Naga A. has started 30 posts and replied 184 times.

Post: My Former Property Manager STOLE My and Tenant's Money!

Naga A.Posted
  • Investor
  • Atlanta, GA
  • Posts 186
  • Votes 14

@Marcia Maynard What do I need to do to do damage control to the tenant?  I already reported to the state RE Commission and filed a request for investigation with them.  

Post: My Former Property Manager STOLE My and Tenant's Money!

Naga A.Posted
  • Investor
  • Atlanta, GA
  • Posts 186
  • Votes 14

OK, I called the clerk at the small claim court.  They told me that my proper manager cannot bring a small claim on behalf of me, only attorney can.  Since I am an out of state (and country) investor, I cannot bring myself to a court.  So, I have to hire an attorney.  Has anybody hired an attorney for a small claim?

I also am thinking of asking my tenant to bring a small claim against my former property manager (Sam Davis of Davis Property Management South) because they stole their money, not mine when they kept the security deposit.  Does it make sense?

Also, when the tenant moves out, do I as a landlord have to give them a security deposit back even though I never receive it?

Post: My Former Property Manager STOLE My and Tenant's Money!

Naga A.Posted
  • Investor
  • Atlanta, GA
  • Posts 186
  • Votes 14

@Christopher Webb  Thanks!

@Curt Smith Yes.  Please PM me for his phone number.   It is partially my fault too because I did not do a proper due diligence simply because he was recommended on BP.    I think he sees this opportunity to steal money as soon as he finds out that I am not local.  Please spread the words about him if you have a chance to avoid future victims. 

Post: My Former Property Manager STOLE My and Tenant's Money!

Naga A.Posted
  • Investor
  • Atlanta, GA
  • Posts 186
  • Votes 14

@Kent Verge Thanks for the info.  Okay. I will file in a small claim court too. 

Post: My Former Property Manager STOLE My and Tenant's Money!

Naga A.Posted
  • Investor
  • Atlanta, GA
  • Posts 186
  • Votes 14

@Dan DeMott  Thanks.   I do not think they are a real property manager and do not know if they are even licensed in GA (it is my understanding that you have to be a licensed agent to manage somebody else's property in GA).  They are contractors doing a property management as a side business.  I should have done more due diligence, visiting their office to check their business operation or checking a license number etc.

Post: My Former Property Manager STOLE My and Tenant's Money!

Naga A.Posted
  • Investor
  • Atlanta, GA
  • Posts 186
  • Votes 14

@Kent Verge Thanks.  I am thinking about it. 

My total loss is about $2000 ($1000 for a rent and $1000 for the tenant's security deposit).  Do you think it worths the cost and effort?

Post: How many of you investors are located in the north side of Atlanta?

Naga A.Posted
  • Investor
  • Atlanta, GA
  • Posts 186
  • Votes 14

@James Park and all other ATL investors on BP

Please DO NOT engage Sam Davis (and his brother, Eddie Davis).  They stole my money and the tenant's security deposit (please see my post http://www.biggerpockets.com/forums/52/topics/1516...).  They are crooks and thieves.  I am filing a police report and a request for an investigation with the Georgia RE Commission against these guys.  Again, do not hire them if you do not want your money to be stolen.

Post: My Former Property Manager STOLE My and Tenant's Money!

Naga A.Posted
  • Investor
  • Atlanta, GA
  • Posts 186
  • Votes 14

My former property manager, Davis Property Management South (managers and owners of the property management company are Sam Davis and Eddie Davis (his brother) whom I found here on BP) stole my money and my tenant's money and refuse to return.  Here is what happened (sorry for a long post).

I found Sam through BP recommended by Curt Smith to engage him for a rehab work on one of my properties (this post, ).  (@Curt Smith , I could not find Curt's original post titled "two ATL contractors I really liked".  Was that post deleted?)

Anyway, after they finished the rehab work, they proposed to manage the property by themselves too, which after negotiations, I agreed.  After a couple of months, they found a tenant and took a security deposit with them.  I was supposed to receive my first rent the first week of September.  However, two weeks passed, I did not receive any money.  So, I sent an email inquiring about the status of the payment and did not get response for a couple of days.  Then, I tried to call them only to find that the phone number I was given was disconnected.  So, I tried to contact them with all other email addressees and phone numbers that I found from the Internet and through mutual acquaintances.   No responses.    

At that point, I was panic, thinking (and knowing) that I was duped and that they took advantage of the fact that I am an out of state (and out of country) investor (please do not start the whole discussions about people should not invest out of state etc.).

They finally contacted me two weeks later to tell me that they were "on emergency leave" and be back in three week.  I told them that I cannot wait for three more week and asked them to immediately disburse the rent to me to which they did not respond.  After several more futile attempts, I terminated the management contract.  

After I terminated the management contract , I asked for the transfer of a security deposit to my new management company and the September rent, they refused, saying that under the management contract they are entitled to keep the security deposit as their one time marketing and management fee. They also said that after the tenant moves out, I as an owner have to pay back the deposit.  I repeatedly told them that the contract does not say such things and that even if the contract says so (which it does not), it is a violation of Georgia Real Estate Law to use Escrow money for any purpose other than damages when a resident moves out of a rental space.  Sam Davis of Davis Property Management South has refused to communicate with me and to return the tenant's security deposit and disburse the September rent to me.

I, through my new property manager, filed a request for investigation at Georgia Real Estate Commission and filed a police report as a “theft by taking”.  Is there anything I can do to go after these guys?  

@Curt Smith

Post: My first deal!

Naga A.Posted
  • Investor
  • Atlanta, GA
  • Posts 186
  • Votes 14

congrats!

Glad I helped you in a small way on your journey to the first purchase.

For the sake of a full complete disclosure, I no longer work with Silas Frazier Realty. I do not want to disclose all the details here. But, I have recently decided to work with another property management company.