@Thomas Sill
Here are a couple scenarios I came up with. Taxes are certainly a concern and would have to be under $2000.
$55,000 Turnkey house
70% ARV rule = Comps need to be worth $78,500
"1.5%" rule = Needs to beat $825 a month rent
Average Rent = $850
50% rule = $425 left for mortgage
25% Down payment = $13,750
Rehab = $0
Closing Cost = $2500
Finance = $41250
Mortgage Payment = $197
Cash flow = $228 [$2736 Annual]
Cash-on-cash = 2736 (annual cashflow)/16250(down payment + closing cost) = 17%
Cap Rate = 2736/55,000 = 5%
$40,000 Fixer Upper
70% ARV rule = Comps need to be worth $78,500
"1.5%" rule = Needs to beat $825 a month rent
Average Rent = $850
50% rule = $425 left for mortgage
25% Down payment= $10,000
Max Rehab = $15,000
Closing Cost = $2500
Finance = $30000
Mortgage Payment = $143
Cash flow = $282 [$3384 Annual]
Cash-on-cash = 3384 (annual cashflow)/27500(down payment + closing cost) = 12%
Cap Rate = 3385/55,000 = 6%