I typed out a huge reply last night then lost it when I hit post due to site Maintance :-/
not to be rude, but please answer my questions if you want me to answer yours.
Have you ever been to Amarillo?
Why invest in Amarillo?
Have you seen this house?
New carpet and windows are nice, but electrical and plumbing problems are real issues, and costly ones at that. The house "looks nice from outside" and better then most investment properties do, yes, but have you walked through it? I haven't (might tomorrow cause I need to see these bubbly walls) but I doubt the agent will allow me to schedule a showing since its under contract.
There's one a bit smaller a few blocks over, but it has a 1 car attached garage. While it does need some cosmetic issues addressed, I looked at it and (don't take this as advise get an inspection) don't believe that property has any major plumbing or electrical issues, it's $5000 less, and its a hud property that has been on the market 45+ days, could prob be had for $35k, and I promise you carpet and paint estimates are a lot easier to get and cheaper then electrical and plumbing issues.
My second concern, correct me if I'm wrong, but I'm assuming your Property manager is also your realtor (or atleast the same company if not same person) and they are also the listing agent for this property. I personally hate when realtors "double dip" because they should be getting you the best price and getting their seller the best price possible, and they often don't seem to suggest negioating in these situations as it just reduces their paycheck.
I don't think your $44k price is a bad price, and I don't think your $650/mo is a bad expected rent, my issue is the unknown which can be huge in plumbing and electrical.
I sold a house a few blocks north on Monroe a few months ago. Outside and roof were nice, needed some paint and flooring and a furnace. Was 3/1.5 with 1 car detached garage I sold for $42, not sure how much he put into it but said he rented it for $850.
These are 1950s and 1960s pier and beam houaes, they not going to be perfect. Do you even know what a pier and beam house is? (Not to be rude but I didn't when I lived in Arizona)
This town is old school, most my deals are done with a handshake, it's just a different market. If your just investing here for cash flow and because you were recommended this area look into cheaper markets imo. Buffalo ny and lots of Ohio come to mind.
If I get a chance I'll go by the house today and check it out