Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 54%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$69 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Account Closed

Account Closed has started 16 posts and replied 62 times.

Post: What part of rental income do lenders consider?

Account ClosedPosted
  • DFW
  • Posts 62
  • Votes 27
Quote from @Patrick Roberts:

For Conventional, there are two basic ways that income is evaluated - properties being placed into service (such as a new property being purchased), and properties already in service. For properties being placed into service for the first time, 75% for the gross rent (based on the appraisal/1007) is used. 25% is assumed as expenses/vacancy. 

For properties already in service, the bottom line on Sched E (or however you're reporting) is used. Start with the bottom line, then add back mortgage interest, property taxes/ insurance/HOA fees (assuming they are escrowed), and any noncash and onetime/extraordinary expenses, such as depreciation. Once you have this figure, net it against the mortgage payment for that property (if there is one). If the net figure is positive, meaning there is positive cashflow, it's added to your gross monthly income. If it's negative, it's considered to be a liability/debt and feeds into your DTI. If there is no mortgage payment at present, escrow items are not added back in the above explanation.

It's more nuanced than this and there are many exceptions/caveats, but this gives a high-level explanation. 

For DSCR loans, in most cases, the raw rental income is used, whether based on the rental appraisal (1007) or an actual lease. Some lenders compare this to only the actual mortgage payment and some include an expense factor. DTI and personal income are not considered.


Thank you for the information! Do lenders use the 80%/75% rule for in-service rental properties(non commercial)? Or do they just go by the bottom up calculation you outlined? I've heard that lenders take your total rent and consider 75-80% of it in your monthly income to get your DTI.

Post: What part of rental income do lenders consider?

Account ClosedPosted
  • DFW
  • Posts 62
  • Votes 27

I'm planning on purchasing rental properties in the near future. Once I've gained rental income, I would like to finance a Condo and even more rental properties with my income from rentals. However, I'm a bit confused on what underwriters consider income when calculating DTI. Do they look at your total rental income (top line, before expenses)? An example: If I have 80k from total rents, but my NOI is 47k (no debt), would I qualify for a 350k loan on a condo?

Post: Quitting everything for full-time investing, big mistake?

Account ClosedPosted
  • DFW
  • Posts 62
  • Votes 27
Quote from @Sam Applegate:

@Account Closed

This is a great question, and while I wish I could give you a direct answer, it really depends on what you want your life to look like.

It might help to figure out your end goal first and then work backwards from there.

For example, if your plan is to buy a few properties and live off the passive income so you can focus on your hobbies, that’s going to be a completely different path than if you’re looking to network with limited partners and start your own syndication fund.

Thank you for the reply! I would definitely like to grow real estate investing into a career. Syndication is definitely advanced and almost a pipe dream at an early age. I live in Los Angeles, so it makes things tricky in terms of flips and in-state investing. It makes sense to work backwards. In that case, having a job while growing slowly makes more sense since I’m lost. 

Post: Quitting everything for full-time investing, big mistake?

Account ClosedPosted
  • DFW
  • Posts 62
  • Votes 27
Quote from @James Mc Ree:

Keep your job!

You asked what are some daily things investors do which says to me you don't know what you are getting into yet. Focus on learning what to do, how to do it and finally do it with your W-2 income supporting you. You don't need to be "all or nothing" to try it out.

You didn't indicate how much wealth you have supporting you. It's not a concern if you are already financially free of the W-2 job.


 I’ve read many books on investing in real estate and realized that it’s not a day to day job. It’s highly passive and there not much to do other than network and marketing. Group meetups are not too often and I would love to be around people on a daily basis. It’s more of a need to do a job on a daily basis and work with others. I don’t have a salaried job right now but plan on getting one soon. I was curious if many investors also have jobs. 

Post: Quitting everything for full-time investing, big mistake?

Account ClosedPosted
  • DFW
  • Posts 62
  • Votes 27

I recently decided to become a full-time real estate investor but quickly realized the amount of time I have on my hands. I’m in the process of getting my license and Ive been doing DMs, barely going outside. What are some things you do as an investor on a daily basis? Do you have a regular job? 

Post: What is it like to be an out-of-state investor?

Account ClosedPosted
  • DFW
  • Posts 62
  • Votes 27
Quote from @Justin R.:

I was living in the Los Angeles area as well when I started my "Out of State" investment journey. I was buying properties in Texas (DFW area) that cash flowed from day 1 (back in 2009.) Texas is difficult as a Californian due to the extremely high Texas property tax, coupled by the CA state income tax. It's a deadly duo.

I continue to invest in out of state rentals but predominantly in the South East. The friendly landlord laws, typically lower tax burden, and population/job growth have made the SE a great place to park assets. 

In general, your most important ally in OOS investing in your property manager. They are your "Hub" and your point of contact/reference for other team members. Agents can be important, but there are too many out there focused in the transaction. A property manager is relationship based, not transactional based. If they tell you property "A" can rent for $2500, then they are the ones who have to put their money where their mouth is. A good manager can make or break you while investing OOS. 

Side tip, if you decide to close without using a agent (not usually a good idea in a new market) then you need to 100% get an inspection (using your own inspector, not the listing agents) and be there during the inspection, title insurance (as always), and have a pre-existing relationship with a property manager. Get their opinion on the property (while respecting their time.)

Best of luck!


 Thanks for the advice! 

I’m curious as to why you chose the south east.

Also, would you consider growing your portfolio OOS? Or is that not viable ?

Post: What is it like to be an out-of-state investor?

Account ClosedPosted
  • DFW
  • Posts 62
  • Votes 27
Quote from @Becca F.:

I would add local experienced investors, property managers and contractors/construction management companies to your team. I talked to two experienced and knowledgeable PM companies that gave me honest assessments of my properties - this was from networking with local investors. They know the rental market, tenant base of different neighborhoods etc. If had talked to those PMs before I made my offers on my OOS properties I would have made different decisions. 

If you're doing a BRRRR (which I don't recommend doing from far away if not experienced), having honest contractors walk properties for you. Some may walk 1 to 2 properties for you, not 10 or 20 (unless you want to pay them for their time) before you submit an offer. I found the renovations costs to vary widely and a couple of contractors said it costs X amount of dollars with no line item estimates (red flag there). I wound up not doing a BRRRR and the ARVs stated by the seller/wholesaler/agent to be on the high side.

Whatever numbers someone (wholesaler/agent) gives you, verify those. It takes time to build up these relationships. 


 Thank you for the tips! Definitely takes time and effort. 

Post: What is it like to be an out-of-state investor?

Account ClosedPosted
  • DFW
  • Posts 62
  • Votes 27
Quote from @Bob Stevens:
Quote from @Brandon Becsi:
Quote from @Account Closed:
Quote from @Brandon Becsi:

I'm in VA and also invest in NC. My suggestion is you can do a lot of networking + conversation's virtually. I think the key is getting 2-3 really good "boots on the ground" in the markets your going to be operating in. These are usually hungry real estate agents usually only a few years into their career and a good handyman or two. People that are part of your team that you can have go look at or inspect a property or even pay $50-$75 to check on a property during the process.

The key is to be a genuine + kind person that wants a win-win and identify others on your team that share that vision because 80% of the people you call/talk to will not be it. You have to weed through them to find the gems. Good luck!


 Network, network. The most important aspect. If I may ask, where/how did you find your best team members? 

Thank you for the advice! :)


 The best teammates I have found is looking at active and sold listing on zillow and seeing what agents look to be doing volume and working with investors. Calling them and having a 10-15 min conversation and see if you vibe with them. Good agents are a great source of knowledge , boots on the ground and can refer quality contractors.  


 Ok so this will cause controversy, you are saying the realtor is part " of your team" ? Come on, 99% of the time the realtor has no knowledge of the property, zero idea how much the reno is and is just there to sell the property. I am contacted almost daily for guidance. I then find out how the investor way overpaid, had no idea how much reno was really needed and so much more. Realtors are not part of your team. I have done let's just say one or two deals, and NEVER use a realtor. You and ONLY you need to know all the numbers. 


 Most agents are definitely not worth working with when it comes to investment properties. I’m not a big fan since all they say is “you need me, you can’t do it without me”. They seem to rarely offer practical advice and drive investors away. There are a very few agents that are good with investors. Most investors recommend that I not have agents involved. GCs, handyman, lawyer, loan officer, and a partner are some people I plan to work with. 

Post: What is it like to be an out-of-state investor?

Account ClosedPosted
  • DFW
  • Posts 62
  • Votes 27
Quote from @Nicholas L.:

@Account Closed

thanks for the responses.  i still can't tell what your plan is =) it sounds like you live in Texas and are staying in Texas... is that correct?  if so... why not 1) house hack in Texas, and 2) invest in Texas?  what am I missing?

also - traditional, vanilla LTRs don't cash flow anywhere right now without some kind of niche or creative or hands-on or intense strategy.  you might be break-even in Texas and negative in California.  that is just where interest rates are right now.

think about putting 20% down on a $200K property.  that's 40-55K.  now say you 'cash flow' $150 a month.  do the math on how long until you recoup that down payment.

not trying to be discouraging, just trying to be realistic.


 I’m originally from California and recently moved to Texas. I plan to move back to California and look to invest out of state. I’m mainly looking to see if anyone had tips on building a strategy for out-of-state investing. I understand how difficult it is to find a deal, but this is a long term strategy I’m looking for.

Post: What is it like to be an out-of-state investor?

Account ClosedPosted
  • DFW
  • Posts 62
  • Votes 27
Quote from @Becca F.:
Quote from @Account Closed:
Quote from @Nicholas L.:

@Account Closed

i am happy to share some perspective.  can you clarify a few things?

1. are you saying you're going to move back to California, and then invest in Texas? 

2. have you considered also house hacking in California?  house hacking where you live does not mean you can't also invest somewhere else.  i always have to ask =)

3. it sounds like you're already doing direct marketing yourself.  that's great!  have you invested before?  or is this just something you're just starting up now?


 Thank you for the reply ! 
1. I would love to move back to California and pick a market to focus on like Texas or somewhere in the mid west. 

3. I’m a beginner but do have a rental in Riverside. I’m looking to sell in California and find something that cash flows out of state. 



For your rental in Riverside, I would lean towards keeping that if it's a SFH or multi-unit and not selling for "cash flow" out of state. The only exception would be if it's a condo with high HOA fees but still might be worth keeping depending on your numbers. How long have you had this rental?

From your response, I'm understanding that you live in Texas right now but at some point plan to move back to CA. Like a couple of people have said, why not house hack in Texas? Live in that property for at least a year then if you move back to CA, house hack in CA if possible. And keep the Riverside rental  for CA appreciation. What do you think your estimated time frame would be for moving back to CA? 


 Hello Becca, 

I’ve had the rental in riverside for about a year now. 

I recently bought a house in Texas which I live in. I plan on selling it in a year and just allocating the money in a rental. House hacking in California would be extremely expensive with lower cash flow. I’m looking to get cash flow over appreciation, so the south/mid west is perfect. Have you been an investor in California exclusively?