Skip to content
×
Try PRO Free Today!
BiggerPockets Pro offers you a comprehensive suite of tools and resources
Market and Deal Finder Tools
Deal Analysis Calculators
Property Management Software
Exclusive discounts to Home Depot, RentRedi, and more
$0
7 days free
$828/yr or $69/mo when billed monthly.
$390/yr or $32.5/mo when billed annually.
7 days free. Cancel anytime.
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Shaun C.

Shaun C. has started 6 posts and replied 256 times.

Post: HVAC repair or replace?

Shaun C.Posted
  • Royal Oak, MI
  • Posts 257
  • Votes 230
Originally posted by @Dave Homyak:
Originally posted by @Shaun C.:

My question is, why do you have two systems for a 1,600 sf house? Have you looked into adding a zone damper system so two thermostats can control one hvac system? That is much more cost effective and efficient than having two systems.

I have one system that is gated and the reason you have 2 is the return air isn't gated, so you are returning from the place that doesn't need the air changed.  Agreed gated is cheaper up front.

A properly designed 2 zone system would have dampers to make it work. Paying for 2 systems doesn't make sense unless your house is 5k sf or bigger. 

Post: HVAC repair or replace?

Shaun C.Posted
  • Royal Oak, MI
  • Posts 257
  • Votes 230
Originally posted by @Casey Culver:
Originally posted by @Mark Fries:
replacement prices seem very high...I can get a new, 2 ton system installed for 2200...

 Right now I have 2 quotes, one for $3900 and one for $4500 from 2 different guys, each local and reputable. How are you arranging this for $2200? Are you buying used unit? Are you buying the unit and then having someone else install? Or do you just have an awesome hvac guy?

By installing the junkiest system he can put in. In Michigan my costs are higher, where we use AC 1/3 as much as Florida. You should be looking at least putting in a 16/18 SEER unit or a heat pump model in Alabama.

Post: HVAC repair or replace?

Shaun C.Posted
  • Royal Oak, MI
  • Posts 257
  • Votes 230
Originally posted by @Casey Culver:
Originally posted by @Shaun C.:

My question is, why do you have two systems for a 1,600 sf house? Have you looked into adding a zone damper system so two thermostats can control one hvac system? That is much more cost effective and efficient than having two systems.

Yeah I thought about it when I first bought the place, but I wasn't expecting to have to change it out so soon. Now that I have tenants in there I don't really have time to experiment what I really know nothing about. Also, it is very very tall, 20+ feet ceilings, so it has volume of a full sized 2000+ sq ft home. 

2000 sf is nothing for a properly sized system. We just upgraded a home two a two zone system and it's crazy comfortable now. Spend the money now for the extra zoning damper system and ducting needed for it to work, or continue to replace 2 separate systems every 15 years...Which would you pick?

Post: Remodel or buy additional?

Shaun C.Posted
  • Royal Oak, MI
  • Posts 257
  • Votes 230

I like having nice things, and tenants that put value on having nice things as well. I rarely ever have to replace things due to wear and tear or neglect. However, these are the same people that are 1-3 years away from owning their own homes; not the people who are perpetually renters. If you plan to hold long term, it's all market dependent. In a recently or mid gentrifying area, I'd probably buy low, fix, and sell after having all the numbers work. But if the area is stable then it only makes sense to replace with things that don't bump the rent too much.

Post: HVAC repair or replace?

Shaun C.Posted
  • Royal Oak, MI
  • Posts 257
  • Votes 230

My question is, why do you have two systems for a 1,600 sf house? Have you looked into adding a zone damper system so two thermostats can control one hvac system? That is much more cost effective and efficient than having two systems.

Post: Locking Egress Door

Shaun C.Posted
  • Royal Oak, MI
  • Posts 257
  • Votes 230
Originally posted by @Justin Swann:

Thanks for the responses. There is no backyard, that would be too simple. I'm going to get in touch with my local building department and see what they say. The rental apt. is pretty unique (3 beds, 3 baths, 2 of which are on suites) with a private rear deck in a nice residential neighborhood, so I don't think a locked door will deter tenants. 

 It will. 

Post: Locking Egress Door

Shaun C.Posted
  • Royal Oak, MI
  • Posts 257
  • Votes 230

You need to call your local building department to see if this is against code, which I would hope it is. I also do not agree with your solution, the problem is the dog, not the tenants, or the front door.

Post: Layout Question for a BRRRR full rehab

Shaun C.Posted
  • Royal Oak, MI
  • Posts 257
  • Votes 230

8x8 is incredibly small for a kitchen, 12x13 is also small for a dining room. I'd combine the two into one. Dining rooms are really too common anyway, and certainly not needed for a rental of that size.

You have already been served with the notice to quit. If they served it properly and timely, you have to move out, or you will be a holdover tenant and they will start the eviction process. From what you've said, you should have taken this more seriously from the beginning. It doesn't matter if there is no lease, there is a set duration for how long the landlord must give when on a month to month lease. It is usually one period (in this case, one month), although it may be longer. You should look up the laws in your state to see if you have more time, or move out by Wednesday.

@Anne Smith

It's been tough the past 5-6 months trying to sell the home. We've probably had it shown 30-40 times as well as a bunch of open houses and everyone says the same thing 'Gorgeous home, but we don't like the road next to it.' We've wen't from $650k, which was honestly a stretch and we should have priced it closer to $600-625k from the get go just to move it, but wanted to see if we could go higher. The price is at $585k now and we should either get asking price or $575k, but not anything lower.

Our numbers when I made this post were also off. After tallying up all the final expenses, we put about $210k into the home, which was almost $50k more than we had planned. I stopped updating our budgeting spreadsheet about a month out, and when everything was over it was pretty shocking to see how much the little things add up. That, coupled with the extra carrying costs means our profit now is more like $60k, which is a far cry from the $150k we thought we would get.

So we're taking this one on the nose a little bit. Don't count your chickens before they hatch is all I would say. It's been a hell of an experience, and I hope to take what I've learned with this one and repeat the process this summer with some homes in the $100-200k range and see how much faster I can rehab them and get them sold. I'm a licensed builder now, and in the process of getting my real estate license so those will be things I can save on as well. That alone would have saved us about $12k on this home.

In the end, we're still making money, and a good amount too, but probably not worth all of our time. I learned a lot, got to turn an eyesore of a home into something much nicer, and much more efficient when it comes to energy use and comfort, so I'm still as happy about that as I was when I originally made this post.