Well, it's finally time for an update...
Due to a number of factors, we re-negotiated down to 144, plus about $1,500 of work to be done on the home, paid for by the seller, before closing.
We showed the house on the 15th after about 3 weeks of gathering prospective tenants. In total, I planned on around 15 parties showing up. Instead, we only had 4. 3 of them were unqualified and the last was uninterested.
As depressing as it was, I took the opportunity to film a video of the home on my iPhone so that I could show the video to any future, prospective tenants. That was the one opportunity we had to show it before closing, which is on the 27th.
I got home from Greeley at about 1:00PM. By 5:00PM, I had received 5 new inquiries on the home. Over the next few days, I received about another 5. I sent them all the video and an application and in total we received 3 applications back, all from qualified parties.
After following up on references, we decided on a party and just received their deposit, first month's rent and the signed lease agreement. :-D
Needless to say, I'm pretty thrilled. I've learned a lot from this experience that I'll take with me when we buy our next property. And I know there is a TON more to learn. And I can't wait for all the opportunities to learn, grow and adjust my strategies to maximize my returns.
But, so far, at least I can say my analysis of the property and the rent it could fetch was 100% accurate.