Originally posted by @Robert Bodmer:
Hello BP, I currently have a property in Baltimore City where some of the tenants on the lease have left and one is remaining. The tenants that are leaving are claiming it is a toxic situation (Have not claimed domestic abuse yet). They (2 out of the three 3 on the lease) want off the lease. The third that is staying claims he has nowhere to go and also says that he will not be paying the full rent since everyone signed. He also claimed he is looking for other places to go but I have a feeling he is going to stay as long as possible paying 1/3 of the rent.
I know all parties are still responsible for the rent payment and if I were to evict, it would be all three. But right now we can't even evict and if we could it wouldn't be that much of an incentive for the two that have left since they already have another home. I've attempted a cash for keys like scenario where I upfront the security deposit back so that the one tenant will vacate but he is not budging.
What options do I have here?
Hey Robert,
As you are probably aware, eviction is a long, drawn out process in Baltimore City. This is a delicate situation since you don't want a squatter, and the remaining tenant likely thinks he can get away with paying 1/3 rent and staying as long as he can.
My property manager has managed for several years and manages over 100+ properties in Baltimore City. Believe it or not, he has never had to evict a tenant in his tenure (many of these properties are in run-down areas). He has always been able to address their problem and figure out a solution.
That's where you come in. I would have an initial phone call with the remaining tenant and make it clear to him that you want to work with him. Listen to his frustration with the other tenants leaving, the potential drama, etc (validate his problems as much as you can).
When I have had tenants pay late, I always let them get everything off their chest and ask open ended questions - then I mention something along the lines of:
"Hey man, I really want to work with you here. At the same time, I have a mortgage to pay, and if I don't collect the rent for this and next month, I may not be able to pay the mortgage - which means I could lose the house. Again, I really want to work with you here. What do you think the best solution is?"
Don't bring up anything about eviction, make threats, or offer to pay him to leave. An open ended question is your first step at solving their problem without stirring the pot.
Usually they understand and will suggest a timeline to move-out, paying rent in chunks, etc. If they push back, this is where you can mention an incentive to have him leave by X date, give him the full deposit back, give him $200 etc. - whatever it is that could be a baby step that would put a little money back in his pocket.
If he's still pushing back, you may need to increase your price to get him out, maybe that's $300, or $3,000. Start with as small as an amount as you have to.
If all else fails, this is where you mention that you have legal options, and that you don't want to use them. This is the truth. The eviction process is long, drawn-out, and expensive - mostly due to the loss of rent.
This whole conversation may take 1, 2 or 3 calls. Judging on your relationship with them, you may be able to meet him face to face to see how you can help him - in person is always best.
I am no expert at the eviction process, and I sure as hell don't ever want to be. I hope this helps.