I purchased a duplex in March 2021, 6 months later a large storm overwhelmed the drainage on the street and significant flooding happened occured. Water of course got into my basement as well as the basements of nearly every other house on the street. Fortunately, the damage was not too significant for me, I was able to salvage the carpet in one unit and only need to replace the carpet in the other unit. My neighbors though experienced much more damage.
I was concerned that this may be a pervasive issue and so I began to investigate the issue further. I spoke with all of the neighbors and they all told me that this street floods like that during torrential storms and one guy who has lived there for the past 40 years said that it was extremely bad in the 1980s and everyone got water. Odd I thought, I don't recall there being any mention of water intrusion on the seller's disclosure. So I went back and checked. The only mention of water intrusion by sellers was "Only ever a tenant caused issue and mitigated in full". Well, that's not what the neighbors are indicating, and definitely not what I experienced here. So I dug further and checked the seller disclosure of the neighboring duplex that I also offered on. Again, the same comment on water intrusion was there "Only ever a tenant caused issue and mitigated in full". So this guy knows there was water in all 4 units he sold but they've all been from the tenants? This seems peculiar to me but I am quite new to this and don't know how I can prove that there were water issues before if the tenants that are there now claim that this is the first time they've experienced it in the 1 year they lived there. Is the previous owner responsible for this water damage?
My other thought was that the water probably shouldn't have been pooling in the street in the first place, the drainage here must be insufficent, so I began investigating this with the county. I call the county drain commission, they tell me they don't have any drains on the road, the road commission owns the only storm drain there. So I call them and they say, we can put a claim and have the foreman come check it out. This is just beginning so we will see where this process goes but would you think the drain commission is responsible here?
I hope that this is not a