@Eric Bilderback I typed up that post and deleted it several times before I was able to actually hit submit. It certainly made me feel rather vulnerable putting the last 10 years of work out there for everyone to see, but I have gotten a lot of good feedback just like I hoped.
@Peter Tverdov Which 3 would you keep?
@JP Gips I have definitely considered going the less houses, less debt route with the focus on cash and reduced risk. Leverage definitely has its risks.
@Virginia Marphis My CPA is an investor and is on BP. I probably need to spend more time talking with him about what I am doing. I do keep detailed records in quickbooks, I just havent really spent any time looking at the reports. When I get a few minutes, I will post some of the numbers here.
@Namit S. My goal was and is to replace my job income. For the second question, to be honest, my criteria has been different. I didnt always have the goal in mind when I was buying. A couple of the houses I bought because there was instant equity and I wasnt as careful about analyzing the cash flow as I should have been.
@Mike Dymski Thanks! The only property I have refinanced is the duplex. The other houses I have been able to do BRRR but in a different order. The bank that I work with will lend based on 80% of the after repaired appraisal value. So most of the houses I have bought since the first couple, I not only didnt put any money down, I got money at closing for the fix up.