Originally posted by @Jonathan Greene:
1) Add a bedroom to a section of the house that has currently windows and 3 walls (was previously used as a den) - this should be a relatively simple upgrade, permitting isn't bad in our county. - I would definitely not do this. Most people think adding a bedroom will upgrade your ARV, but that is not a guarantee if you are creating a bedroom that makes the rest of the house smaller. If it should have been a bedroom, ok, but are you flipping it or BRRRRing it and trying to get a higher refi appraisal?
2) Renovate bathrooms (2 full) - tiling, toilets, vanity. - You never lose money renovating bathrooms, especially in an A+ neighborhood and flipping.
3) There may be a way to add another half bath off an adjacent room to turn into a mini-master bedroom. - Is this on a floor where there is not another half-bath. Your best bang for the buck with adding a bath is when there is none on the first-floor or creating an en suite for the primary.
4) Kitchen - upgrade counter, nice tile for flooring. - Yes, always. You can't be in an A+ neighborhood with a bad kitchen and expect to get paid out.
5) Add a deck off the back walk-out basement double door (it's about a foot drop to step out to the back patio). This neighborhood doesn't have an HOA so I don't think a permit would be required and now that wood has gone back down this may be a good move? - You have to know the impervious cover rules for the town and doesn't sound like a super attractive spot out basement doors for a deck. Maybe you just need a stair drop and call it a day.
@Jonathan Green
1) Not flipping it, using hard money on a rehab so yes I'd like it to appraise higher when our rehab is done. This will be refi'd into a 30yr as an investment property to our LLC.
To give you more of an idea about the bedroom - it's a split level - when you go down into the lower level on the stairs, you can go right or left. So to the right is a bedroom (stair side) and on the right to the far side (across the hallway) is a full bath. If you turn left, it's the den/storage area with 3 walls. All we want to do is wall that area off as a new bedroom and add a closet. Since it's on the lower level and currently unfinished with cement floors, it doesn't count as taxable sq footage. So adding this bedroom isn't going to kill current sq footage and it wasn't being used as a gathering area, it was used for storage (which can still be the case with an extra bedroom). Do you still think it's not a good idea?
2) Thanks, totally agree.
3) Agreed
4) Yeah it's only a foot drop so not sure if we should just leave the patio or add a mini-deck to make it more attractive? Maybe expand/redo the concrete patio instead? Just kicking around ideas to really add value here that an appraiser would really like.
Some other things I thought of -
a) Touch up some fading paint on the alum siding
b) Repaint the metal sheds (there are 2) in the backyard
c) Put a wooden fence in front of any front-facing chain link fencing to increase curb appeal