Originally posted by @Jared Garrison:
@Robert Godfrey
Those used cabinets you are proposing look nice (and are an upgrade) but a few things you need to consider...biggest one being you’ll have to rip out that header above the current cabinets to get those 42” tall uppers in there (a lot of drywall work and mess). Your current kitchen appears to have a “blind corner” cabinet...the used cabinets you’re proposing have no corner cabinets.
IMO...for a flip yes I would replace, for a rental I would just get them painted, new hardware and probably just high definition laminate countertops
Jared good point on the header, though my guy agreed to do the entire kitchen including the tile backsplash so no worries there on redoing drywall. Regarding the "blind corner", that's totally true. If this used cabinet set came with corners I'd probably pull the trigger and just sand/repaint them, however I just matched up the measurements of the current cabinets and they are... odd:
Above the fridge: 33" (+3 inches for the frame, so 36) x 15", to the left of that - a 48" (and not 2 24s nailed together, this thing is huge) x 30", blind corner, then 24" x 30", sink, then 21" x 30", above stove is 30" (+3 inches for the frame) width. So not sure how to handle the weird 33"x15" and the 48"x30", just not something I can find at a big box store though I will most likely have to jam a 36" in and put 2x24" together.
On the bottom from right to left: 18" x 34", 18" x 34", then blind corner, and then under the sink it's wide open to access the pipes... very odd, I guess I could put a 36" under the sink but it would be a huge blind corner. I measured roughly 64" from the left of side of that cabinet all the way to the wall. Then to the left is the dishwasher and then stove to the left of that.
My point is that finding a used set with this many odd sizes would be challenging anyway and the one I mentioned in the Original Post wouldn't work because it was mainly 21" wall cabinets so the 48" killed that option. I'm still looking at used sets in case they have all of these sizes but most likely not.
I should have mentioned that while it's not a flip, I'm looking for a high appraisal on comps to pull out more money for the next rental. Also that this is an A / B+ neighborhood in a great school district with zero crime (some residents even leave doors unlocked). So I feel that the upgrade in materials matches the type of renters I'll have. Otherwise yeah, I'd just do paint/floors/reface cabinets/cheap counter and call it a day. My lender is financing the rehab so cost isn't that big of a deal though the longer it takes, the more interest I'll pay and less money we can pull out for the next deal.