@Jaron Walling, I can personally identify with what you say our mentality is like. "Our" resentment toward Chicago stems from the perception that Chicagoans tend to act as if we are insignificant and they are better than us. ("our" is in quotes because not all of us feel that way, I love Chicago, but I do come across this type of Chicagoan sometimes) As far as associating with Indianapolis, we've never really had a reason to, unless we have family there or something else of significance. It's 2.5 hours away and in a different time zone (sometimes it is... I still can't get that straight). Chicago is 20 minutes away. When we turn on radio and TV, we get their stations and news, we share the Lake (we can see Chicago from the beach in Gary), similar weather, etc. It's only natural that most of us associate more closely with Chicago.
Personally, (before investing) I've never given Indianapolis much thought one way or another, besides the fact that I'd never want to live anywhere so landlocked. I've lived and traveled all around the U. S. and world, and Indianapolis has never been a "hot spot" FOR ME. Don't get me wrong. Lots of people love Indianapolis, and I'm glad it's part of our state. It's just not for me after growing up around the Lake and Chicago. As far as investing, Indianapolis seems to be a decent market. However, being from Gary, I know Gary and surrounding areas better and I'm a lot more comfortable investing here, and (in my opinion) our rental market is just as good as Indianapolis, or better.
I know a**holes from everywhere I've ever been. We do tend to have a lot of pride in our "Region". But it's unfortunate that you ONLY know the a**holes from here, because we aren't all a**holes.