Quote from @Jason Xenakis:
Hello folks. First post. Happy to be here. My wife and I decided to start out of state rental investing in Columbus Ohio. How can one, who has only rudimentary knowledge in real estate without any boots on ground experience (read a few books), effectively choose a real estate agent? We are both physicians and relatively intelligent humanoids, but without knowing what you don't know, it seems a difficult task. Is it about first impressions? The vibe? What are some red flags? What nuanced questions can I ask? Thanks in advance!
Like some of other posts have said, this is a tough scenario. I am both an investor and realtor so ideally, your best bet is to find someone like me in the Cleveland market. I would strongly suggest you talk to a few realtors who own properties in the market(s) you're trying to get into AND then fly to Cleveland (and whatever markets) to meet them in person. See a few properties with them. There are a few things you can do to see who the honest ones are like check to see how many properties they own, how long they've been a realtor, how many sales they have had over the years, etc.
Another option is to speak with other investors on here in the markets that you're interested in, get some info and see if the realtors are telling you a similar story. Maybe one of them has a great realtor in the markets you are considering. There's no full proof way to do this so you might run into issues.