@Kevin Scott seems like you are having a hard time getting the answer to your questions. Let me answer a few from this thread:
1.) Just so I have this straight, is borrowing about 10K from an HML to get me over the hump, then using my own funds for the rest of the dp and the rehab a normal approach?
A.) You can not take out a loan to pay a down payment. That being said, you have options.
- If the property is 4 units or less, it is considered "Residential" meaning you will be receiving a loan from the same side of the bank you would borrow for a Single family house for you to live in. When buying residential property, the value of the property is based on land and structure (i.e location and square foot) and the appraisers professional opinion of the properties worth based on local comps.
- If the property is 5 or more units, it is considered "commercial" real estate. This will mean you loan comes from a different side of the bank where businesses go to receive a loan. The value of a commercial property is appraised differently. The commercial lenders look at the property as a functioning business. As in any business, what it is worth depends on the income it produces. The commercial side uses a different formula. They will take the Net Operating Income of the property (NOI) and divide it by the local market Cap Rate (something you have no control of, Cap rate is essentially the ROI the local market is willing to buy property at) and this will give the lenders a general idea of what the property is worth. An appraiser will still assess the property and make adjustments based on location, age, amenities, and comps to polish off the final value of the asset.
Formula for assessing commercial (NOI/Cap rate = Value) or (Asking price/NOI = Cap Rate)
Now, I say all of that to help you determine your ARV. If you put money into a residential property, it will directly effect your ARV if you make improvements that match the local demographic. If you put granite countertops in an apartment complex in a war zone, you will be throwing money away. The reason is effects it, is because the appraiser will look at the Structure of the property and assess that it is in good condition therefor you value per square foot will increase.
If you put money into a commercial property, you value is determined by the income. This means that with a nicer property, your rents can be increased. Increased rents will show a higher NOI which will then be divided by the cap rate and will show a greater value.
This leads me into question #2
2.) I will do some more research on the BRRRR strategy. I really need to try to figure out how one gets their money back with the refinance if the new appraisal value does not exceed the old appraisal value.
A.) You will not get your money back if your ARV does not exceed your pre-repair value. A bank will lend you 80% of the "cost" when making a purchase, and 80% of the "value" when refinancing. Cost is determined on your negotiation for the contract, and value is determined by the property and market it is in. If you put money into the property to make it better, it will appraise higher unless you make bad decisions such as removing bathrooms and bedrooms, or changing the roof line for no reason. If you do a generally smart renovation such as updating kitchens and baths, paint, flooring, and fixtures - you will see an increase in value or rentability unless your market tanks simultaneously.
That being said, in order to receive ALL of your money back at the refinance, you need to increase the value of the property by $1.25 for every $1.00 you spend unless you enter the deal with substantial equity. The reason for this is because in the end, you are only going to receive 80% of the value from the bank. If you make a $1000 repair, and it increases your value by $1000, the bank will lend you back $800. Just keep this in mind.
Lastly:
3.) Does the bank actually pay out money during the refinance?
A.) Yes, absolutely. They will give you 80% of the value of the property. If your current equity is anything above 80% of the current value of the property, you may receive this in cash. Your mortgage will increase, and you will be paying interest on the money you pull out, so only pull the money out if you need it for an emergency, or an investment. Interest rates are currently low, so borrowing from your equity is an extremely smart decision because this money CAN be used as a down payment on another loan.
Hope all of this helps you. If you have any other questions - feel free to reach out.
Ramsey