Hi @Kendal West - congrats on your first post. I agree with the things @Jonathan Greene mentioned above from the fear/nightmare perspective.
As for the analysis paralysis I'd say this - there is so much to know about REI and so much great information available here and elsewhere that it can be easy to fall into that. My advice would be to narrow your focus. Don't analyze a SFR, then a 4 unit, then a 20 unit, etc. Don't try to compare 50 different markets to each other either. Pick one zip code, or one neighborhood and a specific type of property and focus on that for a while. Eventually, you'll may very well branch out to other areas or property types, but for me, having a super narrow focus (SFR with at least 3BR and 1000sq ft in the 53222 zip code) was extremely helpful in getting me to take action on my first property. Once you get comfortable with that, you can move on to the next one which might be a little different, but much easier now that the ball is rolling. Just my 2 cents.