Welcome to Indy - the poster child for D class property marketed as opportunity! I'll shoot you straight...As a resident of this city and investor, there is absolutely opportunity. But as a few locals have commented, its street by street. The nature of the market - high cash flow, high income to rent, and job growth, makes for a attractive MSA, but please do your research.
If you get on a buyers list, validate the comps that are sent for god sakes. Validate the rehab costs being quoted. I'm on 6-8 buyers lists and the inventory are straight tear downs. Cash flow is overstated, but its there a little, but who's taking the risk here???? The buyer. You will buy but you'll never sell without a major overhaul of the property. Look at the cap ex on a 100 year old property. That's what's being marketed.
Budget for these factors with eyes wide open and you can make a lot of money. There are targets on out of state buyers. Just be aware.