Greetings Fellow BPers,
I have a few buy and holds and am in need of some advice on one that has nose dived. I have a condo that was cash flowing nicely up until about a few months ago ( $1250 Rent -$802.21 PITI & HOA=$447.79 cash flow) In short I was self-managing it since I lived in the same area, but have since moved away.
Over the last year my PITI has increase due to taxes to $837.47. I am now paying $78 for property manager and added a warranty for $50/month. The amount for rent I was able to get decreased (I was renting each room individually for $650 and $600, but now the rate is $1099 for both. Average rent for the similar units is about $900) New cash flow is $132.53/month.
After attending last weeks online Webinar I was able to play around with the BP calculator and get a better picture at the numbers since I did not account for things like 5% vacancy, 5% repairs, 8% capital repairs. Sooo, all that to say in the course of the last 3 weeks I had $2200 in damage done from a nearby unit that flooded (they are paying about 70% of amount) and an old faucet that broke inside my condo (it is old). I have a cushion to absorb these unfortunate series of damages. Sadly, a the current cashflow of $132 I am now at it will take pretty much a year and two months to recuperate this loss, GIVEN there are no more serious damages down the road.
I am really needing some input from fellow investors on courses of action. I did consider pursuing civil court to get the neighbor to pay out the full $1200 in damages, but the time, effort and $150 in court fees deters me from this course (plus the drive for court).
The biggest options I have been entertaining:
+SALE IT: I really don't want to sell, but I am considering it. I should profit $20,000- $25,000 hopefully after fees. I put $20k down on this place, so really hoping to get more than that. I would roll this money over into another property. Only thing that sucks would be the need to forego my business deductions in order to qualify for another loan ( I am self-employed and currently have 2018 taxes on an extension until Oct.)
+ INCREASE RENT: I am not sure if this would be doable since I am already renting hire than comps next door. I was able to get more when I first bought the place because I have some very, very desperate renters who turned out to be more drama than it was worth.)
As I am currently in the thick of all this I am open to other suggestions. I just told my property manager about 30 minutes ago to accept the neighbor's $700 reimbursement for damages* I am also reaching out to my realtor for a more solid CMA. I'd love y'all input:)
* The upstairs HVAC was replaced a few months ago. My tenants downstairs from the installed HVAC reported water coming in through floor area following the install. We had HVAC folks come out who said the upstairs neighbor's plumber did not flush the drain pipe after installing. Turns out since this condo is so old the drain pipe upstairs is connected to my drain pipe...so when everything came down from upstairs it clogged our line and flooded unit. We have had our two HVAC companies blaming the other and our HOA just changed companies...so new HOA cannot verify if old HOA company was supposed to inform HVAC company about drains being linked.