Originally posted by @Mark Gallagher:
I casually browsed the exchange for a few weeks until I was able to find a property nearby that was selling at a significant discount to the unpaid balance (UPB). The UPB in this case is $74,160.32, and the asking price for the note was $4,999.89.
2 things:
1) As Mike mentioned before, always make sure to include taxes in your calculations. 2 years worth of taxes can add up. Remember that a large portion of your notes won't be DIL/workouts, but you WILL have to get far in foreclosure.
So you're looking at note price + legal fees + court costs + taxes + boarding fees + monthly servicing fees + recording fees + commissions and fees if it ends up as a REO + mowing the yard if it has one + HOA fees if there are some + other liens + trash out + boarding / securing the premises + turning on water and electric etc. That's why sub-40 or 50k value loans can be very tricky.
2) Don't look for loans based on a discount on UPB. Always use the lower of UPB or BPO. The UPB only matters if the person restarts paying and you don't go the foreclosure route.
This leads me to what I hate about FCI. Their system is pretty smooth, but they don't control the inventory or the prices and as another poster mentioned you don't know anything about the seller or why they're selling. You can have a gem mixed in with piles of horse dung. That's "okay" if you've bought notes before and you know what to look for, but it is terrible for newer buyers. Thankfully you seem to know the area and you knew it was worth ~$25,000 but what if you were relying on that "significant discount to the UPB"?
I have heard many horror stories of people buying midwest notes thinking they got awesome deals just to realize the notes aren't worth the paper they're written on. That's not FCI's fault, but their system encourages it since the sellers aren't vetted.
Just my 2 cents