Hey Jeff,
Your experience seems pretty common with the new note investors I've met in the past year or two. There are many hurdles that you need to get past one by one, the first of which is finding notes but more importantly pull the trigger and buy the damn thing.
One recurring problem I've noticed is new investors telling me they can't find deals - but when you show them deals they don't buy anyway because they always think the notes are no good.
Little rant here: I put up some notes for sale on the exchanges to try it out and it's been a pretty big disappointment so far for this very reason. The buyers have no idea what they're looking for and just waste your time. I went above and beyond by providing literally everything including due diligence material that no other seller would provide for a 2nd mortgage (ie BPO, Sr lien payoff statement, on top of the usual credit report etc). And they still can't pull the trigger.
"all of the obvious prime investment opportunities are going to be gone"
This is complete horse crap. I've found way more note deals in the past month or two than I have money to buy and I don't have a fund.
Sorry I don't mean to be harsh it has just been irritating me lately. Stop looking for the perfect note; you're not going to find it and if you do, someone with more experience / faster due diligence will scoop it.
So my advice: Find one note seller outside of the exchanges, see what they have and buy one note. Improve from there.The truth is when you're new you only need ONE source of notes. What
good is it to you to look at 1,000 notes if you can't pull the trigger
and buy ONE?
Edit: I see we're already connected. Find a note that looks like you would pull the trigger and send me a message, I'll look at it and see if I notice anything suspicious.