HI BP!
Any and all strategies and ideas as welcome!!
Before jumping into this question, some background for the readers. I am stuck in Analysis Paralysis and need some idea generation to help me move past it from more experienced and savvy investors. Right now, my wife and I own 2 SFHs that are currently rented, and are currently in the process of a new build (another 6-8 months likely). Our goal for 2022 is to move into the MFH space (preferably a 4 unit or more), but need some ideas for funding, or rather the "push" to make us take the leap as I know there are a few options available to us. Ultimately, we are full time W2 employees and I operate a high functioning sales team. Neither of us has an enormous amount of time to manage a rehab, so the idea of building a new MFH is enticing but we are open to ideas. We live in Broward County, Fl and while there are deals to be had, they are hard to find and typically out of our price-point. To put it into perspective, any 4 unit property that you do find (there are not many) are usually no less than $750k to get into and the rent amounts generally dont support the deal. We have 1 SFH in Broward that we currently own $292k on, but is worth about $415k and another home we recently purchased in Ocala, FL that we currently owe $180k on and is worth approx $225k (purchase price we just bought for). The new build home, we are all in for $265k ($240k on the mortgage) or so and when all is said and done, we THINK the home will be worth $325k conservatively. We currently have about $25k liquidity available towards our next deal, which is not significant.
Here are the options that I believe I have at my disposal. Please let me know if you see anything different.
Option 1:
-Sell the SFH in Broward County and walk away with a net of approx $100k before taxes. If we were to take this route, we would try and leverage a 1031 exchange so we aren't being hit heavily on the tax. We did live in this property for 2 of the last 5 years as well if that makes a difference. Use the proceeds to then fund the purchase of a MFH. Can a 1031 exchange be used to fund a new construction?
Option 2: Take out a Heloc against the equity in the SFH in Broward County. I have heard different information, but do believe Navy Federal Credit Union offers 100% LTV for a fixed Heloc starting at 5%, but I am unsure if this requires primary residency status. If this is something that turns out to be possible, I am leaning towards using those funds towards a downpayment on a MFH (new build or existing). My challenge here would be finding enough value add or upside to be able to pull out all of my funds to repay the Heloc when complete with either option. I don't believe we want to look at a cash out refi as we do not want to increase monthly payments on the home, effectively negating our rental income. I like the option of being able to simply pay back at a slightly higher interest rate.
Option 3: Keep the SFH in Broward and sell the new build SFH being built. This would give about $70k or so before tax liquidity. Not sure if there is enough capital there to deploy towards a 4plex though.
Option 4: Keep grinding and playing it out slow to continue to save funds and potentially use one of the strategies above in the next 3-6 months.
Thank you for your time in advance! We are currently looking for REI in mainly Marion County, FL (Ocala) and Cape Coral, FL but are open to other areas as well as where we live in Broward ($$ usually the prohibiting factor).
Patrick