@Nikki Closser
They probably sit on the market due to bad pricing. As a realtor who specializes in rentals, using comps for MF can be very tough because there are only so many MF homes and the quality of area, condition, current rental amounts, ect often get mixed up. Also the show style, pictures, ect has a huge effect. Many cities tend to open up multi family zoning in terrible areas like industrial or near power station or between trains.
You notice this when showing a lot of MF. There is a lot of forced expansion of possible comps and even if you do comps analysis correct you can be very wrong.
Example.
I had a client who wanted to BRRR so we found duplex that was sitting on the market for a very long time. The duplex started at market value but slowly went down. We came in and purchased it and he BRRRed easily. How?
-showings only after accepted offer.
- rents are way under market. (In Oregon that is a NONO)
-realtor phone pic of outside only ( happens a lot with investor realtors sadly)
-the only other duplex in that city for sale was even less $$ but due to terrible condition and train tracks behind it. ( you would not be able to know unless you visited it)
As you see from the points above, many times there is a valid reason for them staying on the market.
Another example was my duplex.
It appraised much higher than it should have for a refinance because I was leeching off the success of better duplexes that were in high value residential neighborhoods. There was a very small amount of MF sales in my town so my duplex rode on the success of the only two somewhat comparable duplexes lol. But I know for sure I would not be able to sell for what it appraised.