@Robin Rinaldi @Mark Miles
Little local knowledge here. I grew up in the Poconos, and have been studying the real estate market there since I was a teenager. My parents bought their house for $300k in 1991, and are currently selling it and hoping to get $400, for a whopping IRR of around 1% per year.
Now... I do happen to know some areas not far from my home, where property prices have increased alongside overall growth in other, hotter real estate markets, that would still be considered the Poconos, perhaps. Take a look around Milford, Narrowsburg, Calicoon, and some other areas that are attracting New Yorkers and the "Escape Brooklyn" crowd who are seeking a more rustic experience than going to the Catskills (off I-84). I know some people killing it--way better than breaking even-- in this space. Happy to share my thoughts for those interested in Poconos. There is definite potential in the region, being the same distance from NYC as the Catskills. In the past 5 years, New restaurants, cafes, bars, art galleries, breweries, yoga studios, concert venues and other interesting stuff seems to be springing up around the Poconos more than I've ever seen. Even in my hometown of Honesdale, PA which had been stagnant, a lot of the above have started to revitalize the town as milennials have opted to stick around for the low cost of living and make their hometown more interesting-- it's great to see!
I even put my family home that's up for sale on AirBNB with mixed success. Again, get closer to the river, and your returns will go up accordingly. Cater to the NYC crowd, and you'll do well. Happy to share any thoughts or insights, as I am a long time airbnb investor and vacation rental manager (we manage across 6 states and expanding fast due to our low cost model). I love this stuff, and enjoy sharing insights about investment returns across markets. Good luck!