Originally posted by @Victor S.:
Originally posted by @Nik Moushon:
I think you are looking at this the wrong way. Not that a pre-nup is right or wrong but how will your S.O. feel about it? How are you going to convince them that you are going into marriage already prepared for it to fail but they should be ok with that and trust you that the marriage will last forever anyways. If you go in treating marriage like a business then don't get up set when the other person finds a better deal, bc its just business after all. I, personally, think pre-nups are a way for people to keep one foot out the door at all times to bc deep down there is something they don't trust about the other person. This is not a foundation you want to start a marriage on. I think you are just setting yourself up for failure. I'm not saying a marriage will last if you dont do a pre-nup as theres a thousand things that could end a marriage. Just this wont help you.
I will add though that I think it could make more sense in a second marriage bc this could protect assets for your children. Though again it still comes off as a trust issue.
Anyways, my 2 cents.
People change. You might marry one person who turns out to be somebody else completely after the fact. Just like somebody mentioned above - probability of marriage failing or succeeding is akin to flipping a coin or playing Russian roulette with half the chambers loaded. Do you like your odds? I certainly don't, and I enjoy a good gamble. Everything in America is business, even relationships. Not a lawyer either, but heard/read that not all prenups hold up in court, so def. get a good lawyer on board if you do decide to go this route.
Victor, I agree. People Change. Thats why I said "theres a thousand things that could end a marriage".
I disagree with your comparison of marriage to flipping a coin or russian roulette. Those are gambling, marriage is not. Those have set chances, marriage does not. Just because the avg of married people divorcing equals the same percentage of winning a coin flip does not mean they are the same thing. There is nothing you can do to change the odds of a coin flip. There a million things you can do to make a marriage last. Not saying theres any guarantees of course. There are plenty of examples of marriages lasting even when they should have statistically ended. Both sides fought to fix what was broken because what wasnt was worth the fight. You can't fight a coin flip. But if you go into marriage treating it as a gamble, as something you just play odds with, something that no matter what you do the odds wont change, then ya...the odds are your marriage will fail bc you've already made up your mind that there nothing worth fighting for bc your fate is set. You let your life be ruled by numbers.
If you're going to reduce marriage to being ruled by set numbers and odds that can't be changed then why are you getting married? Because statistically its a horrible gamble and if the trends continue its only going to get worse.
All I'm saying is marriage is, and should be, more than numbers but if you base it off numbers then don't expect it to work in your favor. Because a 50/50 chance with something this important with only two out comes is not something I would gamble on unless I knew I could do something to change those odds in my favor.