I agree with the other post on this site. I recently pass on a similar situation with a smoking student housing deal (would have to fully renovate the property from shell, but the price was right).
We also tried to roll in a bunch of smaller and similar sized properties to reach economies of scale, but decided that 4 closings and different asset types could be a huge headache.
I am the PM and part owner of our investments, so unless completely necessary I try not to hire other PM companies, but if you have a great deal acting as the asset manager and have a local PM manage the property might be a solution if the numbers work.
Another concern I have is if a small town will support future growth or slowly lose growth over time. In Minnesota I have seen some town flourish and other collapse entirely based on jobs leaving or coming to the area.
In my case it was a growing college town that was expanding, actually the hardest part about walking from the deal. I just know a much bigger better deal is right around the corner, but I I am up to my neck working on this one....I am going to have to pass on the better deal. It takes a lot of time to locate close and turn a property around.