@Malcolm Lawson I totally get your predicament. The numbers for this investment do look promising and even offer just under a 10% CoC return (not counting your 5K appliance costs which knock it down to 8%). I mainly keyed in on your language and "pitch" for this idea and think you have some conflicting thoughts of this as the right investment for you right now. I would follow that "gut" feeling whatever you feel that is. Despite some good numbers, are they home-run numbers worth your cash? This deal could quickly turn into a not-so-much deal, if there is a special assessment in the near future. You hit the nail on the head with what is prominent on my mind right now, money is cheap so leverage into something with more long term upside such as principle paydown and potential appreciation, and put that 70K to real work for you...my opinion would be to hold off for something that will really put that 70K into returning for you. Potentially a pair of 175K SFHs or maybe a duplex. Good luck either way, this deal isn't a loser by any means.