Like @Tom Hamblen suggests, definitely get involved with your local REIA. Everyone I've met at the REIA in San Diego has been extremely helpful and I've heard the same about other cities.
You're correct to assume that STRs are more hands-on BUT there's a misconception about how much time they take because most people don't build a team and system to manage them. They try to do everything themselves... find the property... fix the property... rent it out... clean it -- WHY would any investor want to do the cleaning?!
But once you have a team, it takes much less time to manage. Really, it's infinite because you can just add more team members as you get more properties.
And I don't worry about competition because at least 80% of STR owners don't know how to market their properties. They think they can just post them on AirBnB and the bookings will come rolling in immediately.
Here are a couple of examples:
Example 1: A friend of my is a new Realtor and investor here in San Diego. She bought a 2B/1BA apartment in La Jolla that's a five-minute walk to the beach. She paid $750K -- yeah, expensive which is why I look in other parts of the country in addition to San Diego) and dropped another $50K to reno everything.
She had a professional photographer take photos and she put it up on AirBnB at a competitive price but she got ZERO rentals in over three months while she had to make $15K in mortgage payments.
One Saturday, we were watching our USC Trojans get whipped by Notre Dame with a bunch of friends at a local La Jolla bar. We were pretty blitzed.
Anyhow, she turned to me and said, "I need some marketing advice for my AirBnB listing. Can you help?"
Now, she's one of those people that always asks for advice but never takes it. Even worse, she always says things like, "Oh, that would never work for me because"... BLAH! BLAH! BLAH!
It drives me crazy, so I told her...
"Listen, you know I have a couple dozen clients that pay me a lot of money to help them with their digital marketing, right?"
"Yeah," she replied.
"Well, you've asked me for free advice for a couple of years now and you've never implemented one piece of advice. That's kind of insulting and a waste of my time. So, here's the deal. I'll tell you what to do if you buy a round for the ENTIRE bar. Not just our friends BUT THE ENTIRE BAR."
I didn't think she'd do it but she did. Her tab was like $600.
So, I said, "Alright, here's what I would do and you're probably going to hate me for how simple this is going to be."
"You have a property that you are TELLING people is a five-minute walk to the beach. I know it's five minutes. You know it's five minutes. But people don't believe what they are TOLD. They believe what they can SEE. You need to SHOW... NOT TELL."
"Here's what we're going to do... Right after this horror show is over, we're going to take an Uber to your property. Then you're going to shoot a video on your iPhone of you walking to the beach so that they can see it's a five-minute walk. Simple."
After the game, we went to her rental apartment which, while her apartment is really nice, is in a building that is clean but has a very 1960s feel to it... it's really dated for the wealthy area it's in.
Once we were inside her apartment, I told her, "Here's what you are going to do. You're going to bust out your phone and take a video starting in the kitchen, you're going to tell people that you will prove it's a five-minute walk. Then you're going to simply walk to the beach and, while you do, just point out anything that people would find interesting."
Now, keep in mind that she's this tiny little Chinese chatterbox that was still pretty drunk but she did it.
Stumbling down to the beach, she pointed out the burger joint, the tennis club, the fire department, and a bunch of other things.
And when she got to the beach, she declared, "Look, it took 4:58 to walk to the beach... and I'm hammered!"
Knowing that she might get scared by posting it, I posted it to her listing right away and locked her out.
The next day, she had three bookings! And she's been booked pretty much every day since.
Plus, she has one of the highest rates in the area to which she'll even admit, "I wouldn't rent my place because there are better places that cost less per night."
But her competition doesn't know how to market their listings.
Example 2: This kind of answers your question as to "Why Lynchburg?"
Well, first of all, I was thinking Lynchburg, TN and a tie-in to Jack Daniel's. And I thought Lynchburg was closer to the Great Smokey Mountains.
Wrong on both accounts, I guess!
But the real answer is that I don't really invest in areas. I invest in helping and partnering with people that have the drive to become successful.
There are very few parts of the country where there aren't phenomenal opportunities -- The only place I've refused so far is the Salton Sea area because it's like a post-apocalyptic wasteland.
For example, I'm partnering with a guy I met here on BiggerPockets just four weeks ago that's in a little town in South Carolina that I've never heard of.
He was convinced that this little town had no possibilities but I just jumped on Google Maps and started looking around to see what this little town had to offer.
That's when I saw an equine therapy ranch that helps people deal with emotional and psychiatric problems like child abuse, PTSD, etc. It had a 4.8 with like 120 reviews.
I was drawn to it because I've helped the Helen Woodward Animal Center here in San Diego to market their non-profit.
Then I jumped on Propstream to see if there were any properties that might be available. And I noticed that one guy had recently bought like a dozen properties in the area.
So, I called him and discovered that he bought them through a probate sale. I asked him if he didn't want any of them and he said, "Yeah, there are two on the highway that I don't think I could rent out."
Guess what... these two properties are literally right across the highway. And the seller is probably right about them not making great traditional rentals. However, I felt they could be great STRs if I could market their closeness to the equine center but...
I wasn't sure that this equine center had people coming from out of the area who would need a place to stay overnight or for a few days. Their clientele seemed to be mostly local schools and patients.
Of course, if that's the case, having two properties right across the street wouldn't be advantageous if nobody needs them.
So, I called the center's director and asked her...
"I'm thinking of buying, renovating, and renting out the two houses across the street but I would only do so if you are open to creating a 'camp' or something for people that are out of the area and would need a place to stay overnight. Have you ever considered something like this?"
"Yes, but we don't know how to market outside of our area," she replied.
"Well, I've been in digital marketing for 20 years and I noticed that you aren't advertising on Google. Are you aware that you can get up to $10K per month in free advertising through Google Grants?"
"No. We can?"
"Yes, so here's basically what I suggest. I'll buy those two houses across the street and fix them up to be rented out to your clients. You put together a package for out-of-towners and you mention my two rentals exclusively for at least five years. Plus, I'll help you advertise on Google free of charge. Everybody wins. What do you think?"
Now, she just agreed a couple of weeks ago, so we'll be gutting those two properties starting next week and launching her new out-of-town package -- again, I'm amazed how fast things get done when $700K isn't on the line like here in San Diego.
Sure, I'm taking a bit of a risk -- I can always sell them if she doesn't do her part -- but she strikes me as the type of person that gets **** done and has a passion for what she does. And so does her daughter so I think it's in safe hands for at least another generation.
Oh, and as for the guy I met here on BP, I'm paying him to oversee everything and keep things on track. Plus, we're partnering on some other deals around this little town.
My point with this example is that my partner had a hard time seeing potential right in his own back yard because he didn't see the marketing connection. But because I did, I was able to buy two houses for $10K each -- I'm always blown away that there's not another zero since I live in San Diego -- and about another $20K each in reno.
For roughly $60K, I'll own two STRs that will probably bring in about $3500 per month each. Plus, I get to help a worthwhile charity help others.
Not too shabby!
So, I don't know what's in Lynchburg, VA but I'm positive there's plenty of opportunities for STRs and other investments.