Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: James Hamling

James Hamling has started 14 posts and replied 3801 times.

Post: How U.S. can lower housing prices? And Could Trump look at Broker model as Broken?

James Hamling
Agent
#3 Real Estate News & Current Events Contributor
Posted
  • Real Estate Broker
  • Minneapolis, MN
  • Posts 3,948
  • Votes 5,107
Quote from @Jay Hinrichs:
Quote from @Erik Estrada:
Quote from @Ian Berg:

I agree with you @Jay Hinrichs. When I go to my credit union for a commercial loan there is no junk fees, no origination fee or maybe a half point origination and a better rate. Compared to a mortgage broker that adds on so many fees for the same loan. Most home buyers don't shop loans and just take whatever the mortgage broker is selling them. An agent that works for me has a closing today, when I reviewed their closing statement there was $15k in fees from the mortgage broker. That $15k adds an extra $95 /month to the mortgage that these buyers will be paying for the next 30 years, crazy. 


 The perspective is skewed since you are already in the industry. It’s much different for a first time home buyers that have no experience in buying real estate. On top of that, most referrals to mortgage brokers come from real estate agents. Maybe it might be different in your market, but at least here in CA, no real estate agent is going to refer  a client slow poke big bank unless it’s specialized bank offering a specific program that caters to the needs to the borrower. 


yes it would take a retooling the industry and industry standards no doubt.. But its something that DOGE can dive into :)

 DOGE is hands down, without a doubt, the #1 BEST thing and most needed thing for this country. 

Mandating how a product/service is conveyed to the public NEVER works to lower cost of goods to public, EVER.    History has well proven this out time and time again. 

Gov. mandates, laws, regulations, these are tools to control WHAT the product/service is, think safety focused. mandating no lead in toys, or fall-arrest gear for roofers, things like that, THAT is where it works. 

But to mandate or regulate how a auto manufacturer sells there goods is insanity, at best, and I'd argue quazi-communist at worst. 

The American system is designed for choice, FREE choice. 

It was literally designed to facilitate failure. 

Yes, you read that right, the American system was designed to best facilitate FAILURE not success. because when there is freedom to FAIL, it comes from consumers ability to choose, choose who is worth it, who isnt, and the poor performers fail and the good performers are rewarded. 

And it all thus incentivizes the correct future actions of others. 

The wheels started coming off when we started building in these safety net's against failure. We the people now support a ridiculous number of failures across a myriad of industries. 

Remember all the fantasy promises of ethanol? What a lead balloon that's been, but here we are, still supporting the whole scheme. Why? 

Failure is the required ingredient. Freedom to fail. 

'08' could have been one of the greatest cleansings of our nation in generations but instead we got scammed and then force feed the kool-aid of how good it was that wall-street won out over main-street. 

Now people's minds have been so polluted with this marxist-socialist drum beat for decades that people now default to a socialist answer of "Make Them ____, that's the answer, MAKE EM DO IT MY WAY" and that will fail every time because the very framework is designed to operate opposite. 

Start cutting the favoritism, the golden net's, remove hurdles for small business launch, remove corporate favoritism and watch things correct themself. 

We don't need to "make homes cheaper", we just gotta remove the barriers and special interests that support monopolies, limited competition, centralization, corporate over private, and take things back to middle America, small business, main street over wall street. 

Here is one, remove corporate anonymity. Make corporate leaders criminally and civilly liable for the actions of their organization. ACCOUNTABILITY. This is how it operates in those other countries so often cited as working better. Accountability. 

Government will never succeed in "making" anything cheaper. But it can make things fairer, more liberty centric and that will always achieve the best VALUE in market available. 

There will always be bad actors, you will never regulate malintent away. You have to drowned it out by making fertile ground for good actors to sprout up. 

Post: Off market deals! It’s easy find yourself some off market deals!

James Hamling
Agent
#3 Real Estate News & Current Events Contributor
Posted
  • Real Estate Broker
  • Minneapolis, MN
  • Posts 3,948
  • Votes 5,107
Quote from @Nicholas L.:

@Joe S.

got it, yes for sure it is VERY difficult to source off market deals yourself as a brand new investor.  it's all difficult, i think =) good thread.


Would you call it difficult, or easy, to go pick out a target area this weekend. Print off some contact cards, and literally walk door to door. yes, literally knock, introduce yourself, not selling anything, actually looking for some help. Your a local investor and looking to do some investing int hat area because you really like it and think it a good place. And do they know anyone who maybe could use your services or could be a good fit for what you're looking for. 

Yes, back in the day when I was brand spankin new this is literally what I did, every flippin weekend. I walked, knocked doors, meet people, shot-the-breeze on the lawn. 

I was pizz-poor, totally clueless on how to find a deal so I just did what I could, knock doors and ask. 

I would call it easy. Not all that complicated, really. 

Take a bunch of time, sure did. Did it suck at times, oh hell-yes it did. But there was good times too. And I fumbled myself right into some amazing deals just simply walking around, knocking doors, talking to people. 

Post: Off market deals! It’s easy find yourself some off market deals!

James Hamling
Agent
#3 Real Estate News & Current Events Contributor
Posted
  • Real Estate Broker
  • Minneapolis, MN
  • Posts 3,948
  • Votes 5,107

@Joe S. 

Is it "easy" to find "off market deals"? If your using the word "easy" in place of "simple", well heck-yeah! 

Proof? The MLS.

Fun fact, >98% of every property on the MLS, was an off-market property until the agent/broker put it on the market.

And, ok let's just be honest here, just gonna say the silent truth of it, theres a reason no real estate agent has ever won a Nobel prize.... 

I mean come on, we all know it don't we, Mensa is not exactly swelling with ranks of real estate agents right. So great levels of intelligence it does not take. 

So, how is it daily that this league of "Joe Dirt's" can source literally thousands of off market properties across that nation if it's not "simple"? 

The rub is, just because it's "simple" does not mean work is not required...... And that the work is simple, easy, fun or enjoyable. 

Can mailers work? Yes they can.... IF you put in the work. 

Can door knocking work? Yes, again, IF you put in the work. 

SEO, cold calling, networking, hitting up probate attorneys, hanging outside the funeral parlor..... ok maybe not that one but point is the strategies are all but endless AND THEY ALL REQUIRE WORK. 

Some are more efficient than others, some WAY more efficient (shout out to @Jerryll Noorden) but with 1,000% certainty THEY ALL REQUIRE EFFORT. 

Why is it said to seek "Off-Market"? Because first and foremost it requires you getting INVOLVED, putting in some rep's, and if you won't get involved and won't put in the rep's you will never, I repeat you will NEVER succeed in investment real estate or any business venture EVER, full-stop. 

Second, because when you are connected 1-2-1 as you will be in an off-market potential, there is a flow of information that can never happen with intermediaries in between. Rapport can be built. Ideas bounced back n fourth. It can be a conversation in search of a win-win, a mutual effort vs adversarial negotiation as on-market is designed to be. 

Success requires effort people, always has and always will, there is no work around. 

Post: How U.S. can lower housing prices? And Could Trump look at Broker model as Broken?

James Hamling
Agent
#3 Real Estate News & Current Events Contributor
Posted
  • Real Estate Broker
  • Minneapolis, MN
  • Posts 3,948
  • Votes 5,107

@Jay Hinrichs wouldn't eliminating Brokers decrease competition, and access to competitive offerings? 

Isn't the exact opposite what we need? More competition, more competitive offerings? 

Post: What Do You Think Of All Of The Reverse Trolling in the Forums?

James Hamling
Agent
#3 Real Estate News & Current Events Contributor
Posted
  • Real Estate Broker
  • Minneapolis, MN
  • Posts 3,948
  • Votes 5,107
Quote from @Jonathan Greene:
Quote from @James Hamling:

@Jonathan Greene I think it's all about intent. 

For example, if the guy with the CRM company is asking the CRM questions because he actually is seeking the info from the public, what they like, hate, need, want, so he can go back and use that info to better what he's doing, hey high-5.

Unfortunately, that's maybe what, 1:1,000.... 

Other than that, yeah, it's annoying. But, I bet-ya it's also effective.  


I completely agree with that and there is a way to phrase it when you are not trolling by saying, hey I own a CRM company and am honestly looking for feedback to make the product better (and then do not send DMs). That is smart business.

Most people, as you said, just fake it so poorly. A lender, "how about interest rates, wow." Ok buddy.


Yeah, 100% agree. 

And I'd hope people have enough wit's to figure if someone BS's their way to get "biz leads" there probably going to BS their way through/around anything/everything else.     

It's deceptive practice, plain n simple. 

Post: What Do You Think Of All Of The Reverse Trolling in the Forums?

James Hamling
Agent
#3 Real Estate News & Current Events Contributor
Posted
  • Real Estate Broker
  • Minneapolis, MN
  • Posts 3,948
  • Votes 5,107
Quote from @Bruce Woodruff:
Quote from @Jonathan Greene:
Quote from @Bruce Woodruff:
Quote from @Scott Trench:

I think that the team and moderators will all be aligned with this philosophically. 

But, I think in practice, "reverse trolling" remains ill-defined and a blurred line will rapidly begin developing. 

Any ideas on how to crystallize this? 

Any suggestions on what to update/populate in our "rules" section to help us make this clearer? 

I really think that this is not necessary (with all due respect @Jonathan Greene)

The forum is great and works just fine IMO. The trolls are obvious to anyone with a little sense. The 'good guys' on here can help the newbies by pointing out the very obvious trolls......

Just my $0.02


I think if we have active moderators and active community to help put them back in the bag it will be fine as well. It's not a giant burden right now, but with AI and duplication posts, it's becoming much easier to spam overall.

I still find the biggest 'issue' on the Forum is what we've already talked about - the failure of most new members to use the search feature before asking the same question that has been asked over and over again. How that gets fixed I have no idea, I'm sure it is a problem on every forum out there.....but it bogs down the Forum and wastes people's time more than anything else IMHO...

It's people Bruce. 

Almost daily I get a phone call of: "Hey, I am calling on your property listed for rent (that they are obviously reading because that's how they got my #), I was wondering, is it available?". 

It's been years on end I have been doing this and still, to this day every time I get asked this question, I so desperately want to say "Nope! Not available. I just like to list places and keep them posted so I get a chance to talk to nice new people, like you. So, how's it going?" Lol. 

But I get it, plenty do keep places posted that are no longer available, so I am nice, I answer. But, then when they ask me the rent, the terms, available date...... I tell them it's one quarter inch away from where they looked at my #, READ THE LISTING. No, they don't almost never.     Because it's too much energy to take 2min to read it, instead they just read for a #, and call me to ask everything they just refused to read in looking for my #........ 

I assure that's what's happening here, it's a generational thing. 

I miss the good ole days, when you could tell an idiot there being an idiot.... 

Post: What Do You Think Of All Of The Reverse Trolling in the Forums?

James Hamling
Agent
#3 Real Estate News & Current Events Contributor
Posted
  • Real Estate Broker
  • Minneapolis, MN
  • Posts 3,948
  • Votes 5,107

@Jonathan Greene I think it's all about intent. 

For example, if the guy with the CRM company is asking the CRM questions because he actually is seeking the info from the public, what they like, hate, need, want, so he can go back and use that info to better what he's doing, hey high-5.

Unfortunately, that's maybe what, 1:1,000.... 

Other than that, yeah, it's annoying. But, I bet-ya it's also effective.  

Post: What qualities to look for in a good agent? Trying to learn as a new agent

James Hamling
Agent
#3 Real Estate News & Current Events Contributor
Posted
  • Real Estate Broker
  • Minneapolis, MN
  • Posts 3,948
  • Votes 5,107

BE - OF - SERVICE ....... 

Yes, it really is that simple. 

Literally everything one should, or shouldn't be, do, know, act, will all be correctly guided from those 3 words. 

Because you can't be of service, if you are not skilled, so one will get skilled. 

And you can't be of service if you don't communicate well, so one will communicate well. 

And you can't be of service, if your not delivering value, so one will make themselves of value. 

So it really is just that, BE OF SERVICE. 

No jazzy tools, BS booklets, word-salad info whatever's, just BE OF SERVICE. 

And it also means to attack everything like it's your Mom's, like it matters, truly matters, because if you only care about a paycheck you are not serving your looking to be served. 

Most fail because that exact reason, there why is SELF-serving. GIVE 2 get. Ignore the get just focus on the GIVE, everything else will take care of itself. 

BE OF SERVICE ....

Post: How to choose a location from the US?

James Hamling
Agent
#3 Real Estate News & Current Events Contributor
Posted
  • Real Estate Broker
  • Minneapolis, MN
  • Posts 3,948
  • Votes 5,107
Quote from @Mike Tikh:

Currently stuck in analysis paralysis on trying to find the right location for a first property, with a willingness to move anywhere in the US. 

Goal

My objective would be to go with a MFH, 2-4 units, higher would be better. I'd house hack and live in one of the units the first year, and use an FHA 3.5% loan. For amount, it would likely be in the $500-700k range.

My expectations are to have a negative cash flow while living there, and possibly a slight negative cash flow after moving out (until interest rates lower or rents increase). For example, a $650k 3-4 unit where each can rent out at $1,500, allowing for a negative cash flow of $2-2.5k/month the first year.

Possibilities

Given those goals, it would rule out the more expensive places (California, Seattle area, Austin). However, I have no idea how to choose from the remaining cities, it seems there are a lot of potential options:

Midwest - Michigan (ie: Grand Rapids) seems to have options, also seeing Columbus Ohio and Indianapolis coming up

Reno - I've seen mentioned several times on here

Pittsburgh / Philadelphia / Twin Cities - All mentioned as lower cost to get started, and seem to be experiencing growth

I'd ideally like to find a place that has strong potential for future growth, a diversified economy, and I don't mind living in (being close to nature would be a plus). 

Any thoughts on how to choose - what metrics to evaluate, resources to read to help?

 Lol, Twin Cities experiencing growth, that's the understatement of the century. 

Here is a few suggestions to help whittle down focus a bit more. 

Do you want to be in dense developed urban (such as Minneapolis), or surrounding urban (Bloomington, Richfield, Edina etc.) suburbs (Maple Grove / Plymouth) or semi-rural "path of progress" (Otsego, Monticello). 

And this should be a "living and working in ___ environment fit's good with my life" kind of things. 

Next, and you may be surprised, what hobbies and other interests are important?    Look, it matters being happy where you live, it does. So if your big into water sports, living in the desert could have all the profit in the world but it's going to be miserable hell and odd's are after some months the profits wont matter. And vice versa. So, it matters to also have a life style fit. 

Lastly; NUT-UP! At some point your just gonna have to jump, perfect is a process not a place. If you don't hold you accountable, if you don't push you, well, the worlds happy letting you be a bystander to life. 

Post: Questions to ask on an 8-plex

James Hamling
Agent
#3 Real Estate News & Current Events Contributor
Posted
  • Real Estate Broker
  • Minneapolis, MN
  • Posts 3,948
  • Votes 5,107
Quote from @Chris Kittle:
Quote from @James Hamling:
Quote from @Chris Kittle:
Quote from @Nicholas L.:

@Chris Kittle

that's a big one to start with.  not to say it can't be done, but it would be a lot if you've never owned anything before.  have you looked into house hacking?

here are some questions off the top of my head.  do you have a professional representing you?  is it on market or off?  why is the owner selling?  how many units are occupied and how many are vacant?  are the tenants in good standing or are some behind?  are they on leases or month to month?  are the rents at or below market?  does it cash flow now?  could it cash flow with rent increases?  are rent increases realistic?

Thanks for those great questions!  I am a busy W-2 professional with a paid off house so I'm not worried about where I'm going to live.  I also don't have time to personally manage a complex like that but I have identified a property manager that charges 10% of rent to manage the units.  He comes highly recommended and I have spoken to him personally and feel comfortable moving forward with him.  As for your other questions:

It is currently on the market and has been so for several months

I don't have anyone representing me yet...trying to learn as much as I can before taking that next step with a realtor

I don't know why the owner is selling

I don't know the standing of the tenants

Rent appears to be at market

Assuming 10% vacancy rate, my calculations show that it would indeed cashflow.  

Again thank you for posting those questions as those are some of the things that I need to ask the seller when I reach out.


I'm confused Chris.... 

You found a PM who's specialized to this exact market and property type. Highly rated and you feel great after connecting with them. 

Why wouldn't you ask them to sit you down and give you the "download" on everything you should know to do this? 

Ask them if $500 would be fair enough for a day or few hours of education. 

If they are the quality PM you say they are, there is nobody who is going to know more or give it to you straighter then them.


 Let’s put it this way…I’m so green that I don’t know what I don’t know.  Utilizing the years of experience from the people on the forums will allow me to talk intelligently with a realtor, the property manager, the seller, and so forth.  I really do appreciate all of the comments folks have made and it’s clear that they have systems in place and I hope that knowledge will aid me in my endeavor. 


You missed my point. 

Point is, by your own statement you already have the best resource available, at hand, to answer all of this, and then some. 

That PM, if they are what you say they are, would be you're "Obi-wan". 

PM's know a hell of a lot more than transactional agents do in vast majority. Ugly truth is the vast majority of agents out there have no knowledge, conceptual knowledge, or exceptionally limited knowledge in this regard. 

 A PM of worth at let's say yr7, has done hundred upon hundreds of listings, and dealt with a range of properties and tenant situations most transactional agents will never experience in their entire life time. Just a fact of the #'s. 

Take my office for example, we have over 1,400 doors under management in just my office alone. We see more and experience more in 1yr than any transactional agent in our market ever does in their career.

We can answer those question from in-the-moment 1st hand experience, what is happening now, what happened before, and where it's all leading. From real-world, not theory or something we heard or read, but from DOING. 

A transactional agent is best for exactly that, the transaction, how to in contract negotiations, how to get under contract, get best deal in contract and sometimes how to dig up and create a purchase potential or how to best sell. 

if you want to know about operational wise, speak to those in the operations side of things.