Hello Jesse! I just went through this situation on my house when my wife died from cancer. In the beginning, my brother had me convinced to lease my house out, which was free and clear and had an ARV of about 400K. He thought my return would be over 20% with the money borrowed for the needed repairs. One thing I did not anticipate was his heart attack. Thankfully, he survived but spent a couple of months in a hospital and I was handicapped and could not even walk. Since I could not count on his assistance, I ended up selling and "walked" away from closing with $224,000 after all debts were paid.
The bottom line is that you can never count on the future or that it will be good to you and it is hard to predict. At 54, I never imagined that I would have a brain anneurrism and a stroke two days before my planned surgery to correct my problem that my head surgery would correct. That was almost 10 years ago today and in some ways I am happy and in some ways I feel cursed. I still cannot walk and have not worked since 2010 when I owned my own business. I'm lucky I paid off my mortgage in 1996 but was unable to be involved with my daughter who was in high school.
I was not able to see her graduate at The University of Arkansas. The good thing, was that she turned out fairly intelligent and graduated with zero debt as a chemical engineer. She now works for a Ft. Worth company that prints US money and she cleans their air and water. Just to give you an idea, is that the employ about 1000 people and they are very busy right now. I was lucky that my wife took care of me for 9 years and her employer was so good to both of us. She was a computer programmer and made pretty good money.
Again, you cannot predict the future and you need to try to prepare yourself for anything that may happen. If you can have a positive cash flow that covers all it's expenses including the debt. You can zlso profit from its' inflation and where it is at. Is it be in a growth area, a good school system, in a low crime area, nearby amenities, its' ability to be used as a new virus change that is allowing for office or exercising. What is the demand in that area? Can you keep it leased out? Can you build maintenance reserves for minor and major repairs?
Can you afford any out of pocket expenses that may come up with repairs or debt payments? My intent is not to scare you but you need to consider everything to take that extra possible burden. It might just be better to walk away and forget about it. Does your present employment easy or hard to get away from? There are many things to consider. Is the possible maintenance cost look good or bad? You are hearing from a person that was a licensed broker and into construction for about 30 years in Dallas, Texas.
Good luck to you!