Skip to content
×
Try PRO Free Today!
BiggerPockets Pro offers you a comprehensive suite of tools and resources
Market and Deal Finder Tools
Deal Analysis Calculators
Property Management Software
Exclusive discounts to Home Depot, RentRedi, and more
$0
7 days free
$828/yr or $69/mo when billed monthly.
$390/yr or $32.5/mo when billed annually.
7 days free. Cancel anytime.
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Melanie P.

Melanie P. has started 3 posts and replied 1034 times.

Post: Older Investor needing help getting a Second property

Melanie P.
Pro Member
Posted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Posts 1,048
  • Votes 844

There are sources to obtain the financing you want to buy more property. But is it worth the hassle? You start by mentioning your age... you'd need everything to go just right for the rest of your life to make, best case, $400 or less additional each month net cash flow. Any repair issues the new acquisition has you will feel to much greater magnitude due to the property carrying a lot of debt. I think you run a real risk of your second rental eating up the profits you're enjoying on the first one. Two doors doesn't provide any sort of scale to make the cash flow more predictable. i would think hard if this is really worth your time, money, and effort...

Post: Thinking out of California

Melanie P.
Pro Member
Posted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Posts 1,048
  • Votes 844

Congrats. When are you moving?

Post: What's it been like investing in Columbus? Where should I invest?

Melanie P.
Pro Member
Posted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Posts 1,048
  • Votes 844

Chicago has great suburbs to invest in. There is no reason to invest in Ohio if you'll be living in Illinois. 

Post: Mass deportations: will it affect rental markets?

Melanie P.
Pro Member
Posted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Posts 1,048
  • Votes 844

The massive wave of illegal immigration has added to competition for housing. Without question. it follows that if you could deport 5.5 million people quickly, or even incarcerate them pending deportation, that it would ease pressure on rents, housing prices, availability, etc. In my opinion, this will not have a major effect because new immigrants, legal and illegal, will always outpace deportations. 

Post: What is considered a good cash flow?

Melanie P.
Pro Member
Posted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Posts 1,048
  • Votes 844

In my opinion a number that is positive at the end of the year is "good cash flow."

Real estate takes time and scale to produce reliable cash flow. Some of our units that lost money the first year or two of ownership, after 35 years produce more than their purchase price in positive cash flow every year. Even once you have a unit going well a huge repair or tenant default with inadequate CapEx reserves swiftly returns it to negative cash flow.

Post: need help structuring terms for a multi family or apartment complex

Melanie P.
Pro Member
Posted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Posts 1,048
  • Votes 844

What is the target acquisition price and how much capital do you have ready to deploy immediately? Please summarize your real estate experience.

Post: WARNING - Justin Goodin is Operating as Goodin Development

Melanie P.
Pro Member
Posted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Posts 1,048
  • Votes 844
Quote from @Justin Goodin:
Quote from @Melanie P.:

If you've been around these forums a while you may remember @Justin Goodin of Next Level Equity. He used to troll these waters for suckers very hard until I found out that his claimed experience and transaction history was fake. Deals he claimed to have "closed" were not his firm's deals, despite being listed on Next Level Equity's Portfolio page and Justin creating and posting graphics with Next Level Equity's logo the word "CLOSED" and pictures of other people's real estate. Justin made posts here about how much "he spent" rehabbing units that wound up belonging to other people. I wrote about this extensively here and also made reports to the SEC and FBI. Well, surprise, surprise the phony investment firm up and disappeared. Thankfully you can still see what he put on the Next Level Equity site here: Next Level Equity Archived Site

Unfortunately Justin Goodin is back with a new "premier investment opportunity" he's calling Goodin Development. If you compare the sales pitch between Next Level Equity and Goodin Development  you'll hear a familiar tune with the names changed to protect the guilty. This time you supposedly have the opportunity to invest in multii-family under development. His site makes the following claims:

"We are honored to partner with the City of Fishers to build this vibrant community near downtown. District South has a priceless location that backs up directly to the famous Nickel Plate Trail." Yesterday I reached several Fishers' City employees and a member of the Nickel Plate Review Committee none of whom had ever heard of Goodin Development. I was referred to the actual developer, Rebar Development, by City of Fishers and am waiting to hear back from their Corporate Counsel.

"District South was financed with a fixed interest rate construction loan from our partners at First Financial Bank NA. We started construction in February 2025 and are planning to start leasing up in Spring of 2026.First Financial Bank has no record of having done business with Goodin Development. Goodin Development has no filings with the SEC authorizing it to raise money, has not pulled any permits and is not mentioned in any of the numerous news articles discussing the development and the companies involved.

If you are thinking of sending Justin Goodin or Goodin Development any money - THINK TWICE!! USE EXTREME CAUTION!

I will update my reports to federal law enforcement about these activities once I have completed debunking all of his new claims. I'm also hopeful to get some local cooperation now that he's claiming partnerships with local government. Of course, he is free to come here and prove me wrong. So far that hasn't happened, despite being given every opportunity to do so. Be safe out there.


 
Melanie, I don't appreciate the constant false claims about me as a person or my company. I take slander very seriously. I sent this post (and many more) to my attorney today so he will be in touch soon. Have a great day.

 Justin - 

I'm not the one making false claims, you are. In fact, the whole of my experience with you is that most of the things you say in connection with the "investments" you are peddling turn out to be lies. For example the first text on Goodin Development's web page says:

"We build premium, market rate communities throughout Indiana and help busy professionals invest in real estate, without the hassle of having to analyze properties, manage tenants, or deal with any repairs."

1) Where has Goodin Development built or are you building anything whatsoever? Can you show a single building permit from any time, ever, that indicates Goodin Development has ever completed or is working on a permitted project?

2) You say "throughout Indiana." Where specifically in Indiana has anything been built? Does Goodin Development have offices or assets located anywhere else in Indiana other than where you live?

3) You help people invest without the need for them to analyze the underlying properties? Please explain. Are you licensed to recommend investments (i.e. financial advisor, broker, dealer)? What qualifications do you believe you possess that would make you a good candidate to advise others on the quality, safety and performance of potential investments?

4) What happened to Next Level Equities? How come shortly after questions were asked that you could not or would not answer the website disappeared from the Internet? Did you have any investors there at all? If you did, do they know how to reach you now?

If what you're doing is so wonderfully pure and I'm just too stupid to understand your mastery of the industry why do you have to constantly lie, mischaracterize and misrepresent to raise money? Certainly even someone of your intellect must understand that if you're lying all day in order to promote investments that you do not have a sustainable business model. You make it so easy, you're so obvious, one need not travel further than the second sentence on your web page to find the first lie -- you may find yourself being accountable over silly practices and small dollars. Meanwhile, others who had boiler rooms, or several of you (money bundlers -  aka "fall guys") will emerge unscathed. 

Post: New Beginnings 2025

Melanie P.
Pro Member
Posted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Posts 1,048
  • Votes 844

You should estimate th property value using recent sales data. Having an idea of the appreciation is an important part of keeping score. Knowing where you actually stand enables you to plan the next one with greater certainty. 

Post: Stay away from RAD Diversified

Melanie P.
Pro Member
Posted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Posts 1,048
  • Votes 844

I love that this boiler room clown, Dutch "da loser" Mendenhall, titled his book Money Shackles then used it to put himself on the road to a real set of shackles. Totally out of control. Total loser.

Post: First Time Real Estate Buyer - Seeking Advice on Single Family VS Mutli Family Units

Melanie P.
Pro Member
Posted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Posts 1,048
  • Votes 844

Living in a great travel destination like Sonoma you should consider a duplex or triplex and operate the other unit(s) on AirBNB, VRBO, etc. You'll achieve a higher ROI. Your partner is right there if you need to fill in for an absent cleaner or resolve a guest issue.

Another benefit is that you won't be around long term tenants who know you own the property, resent you for it and place unreasonable demands on you since they feel like they know you. Every guest is a stranger.