Zillow doesn't give an estimate for this house in particular, but their average for New Castle is $65K, and their average for that zip code is $78K. So if it's listed for $19K and is 116 years old... there's something wrong with it. :)
The county tax history is kind of interesting. https://beacon.schneidercorp.c... The county valued it at $89K until 2016, then $53K in 2017 and 2018, and now $22K in 2019. So why did it drop off like that? County valuations are not always super accurate, but they can give you some kind of idea - so just based on that, it may need somewhere between $34K and $70K of renovations.
It also looks like it may have gone to a sherriff's sale in 2013 and got bought by Fannie Mae, who then sold it in 2015 to someone, who is presumably the current seller.
Until I knew different, I would assume:
- you need to replace the roof (shingles), and possibly the wood under the shingles too. From the pictures, you also need to fix some of the wood under the eaves. Probably a few thousand dollars.
- you need to do work on the foundation. This varies a lot, from maybe a couple of thousand dollars to tens of thousands.
- you need to rewire the whole house. The photos of the bedrooms show only a couple of outlets, which often means that it still has some knob-and-tube wiring. If original, the insulation on that wiring is at about three times its design lifetime. The main fuse/breaker panel has probably been replaced since the house was built, but don't assume that the wiring has been replaced just because the panel is new. Maybe three or four thousand dollars for the materials - plus labor if you don't DIY.
- you need to insulate all of the outer walls. The house was probably built without any insulation at all. It may have had some added over the years, but maybe not everywhere, and probably not that much. You can estimate this yourself by figuring the area of the outside walls, and then pricing rolls of R-whatever insulation at the friendly local home store.
- you need to get rid of all the lead-based paint. This involves plastic sheeting, fans, bunny suits, and a place to dispose of the stuff you tear out. If you have to hire it done, figure on several thousand dollars. Even if you DIY, plan on a thousand or so for the sheeting, bunny suits, disposal, etc.
One thing that works in your favor, is that if you plan to demo all the plaster and put up new drywall, that makes rewiring and adding insulation much easier. Demoing the plaster also takes care of most of the lead paint.
I agree with the idea of keeping the wood floors, if possible. Also keep the woodwork on the first floor - those nice doorways and doors.
Free advice:
Hire a home inspector on your own (not one recommended by a realtor), and get one that has experience inspecting houses that old. Pay the trip charge for them to come out from Indianapolis if you have to.
If you're going to make this a rental, check to see what the city requires for that. If you're doing a full-gut renovation, they may require things like AFCI circuits in the bedrooms and wired smoke detectors. Usually the things they want aren't particularly hard to install, but it's better to know about them ahead of time. They may also want it to be professionally de-leaded, which is expensive.
If you're going to make this a rental, consider blocking off the fireplace. Ask your insurance agent how much this helps.