Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Matthew Wolk

Matthew Wolk has started 1 posts and replied 77 times.

Post: Does my business impact my DTI ratio

Matthew WolkPosted
  • Lender
  • Tampa, FL
  • Posts 79
  • Votes 27
Quote from @Dyami Pike:

I'm looking to buy my first investment property and I had a question. 

I own 40% of an LLC. Do the debts incurred by the business impact my DTI or are they viewed as a separate debt?


They are separate if they are through the LLC. You could also look into a DSCR loan as well if you are worried about DTI.

Post: Should I purchase my first real estate property as owner occupied

Matthew WolkPosted
  • Lender
  • Tampa, FL
  • Posts 79
  • Votes 27
Quote from @Erica Ho:

Hi all,

I am hoping to start my real estate investment journey and can't decide between either co-buying my first real estate property in LA vs buying an out of state investment property. 

For the first option I would co-buy with my sister who would then occupy the house and help find and manage renters. Co-buying would make it easier for me to pay a down and mortgage in an expensive area like LA and hopefully we could qualify for some owner occupant benefits (not sure about the details there). My concern with LA is that it would be difficult to find a property that works given the high prices and I'm not sure if I would take advantage of FHA loans because of it's high mortgage insurance cost.

On the other hand, I had initially thought to invest out of state by myself in a much more affordable home and rent out the place through a property manager. However, I would then need to purchase an investor mortgage and also I wouldn't be as familiar with the real estate market. In addition, I'm not clear on whether owner occupant mortgages are significantly better than investor mortgages.

I would be renting in both cases since I currently live in NYC and am not sure where I would want to stay long term. A third option I am entertaining is that I move out of state and house hack but that would be longer term as I haven't decided where. Wondering what others think or even details/things I have not considered. I am pretty lost here as to how to best get started...any advice would be welcomed. Thank you!


 Erica,

Congrats on beginning your house hunting journey! If you want to get a primary home you will be able able to do as little as 3% down and your rate will be around 1.5% better. Depending on your credit score, the PMI might be even higher on the conventional than the FHA monthly mortgage insurance and you get a lower rate on an FHA loan. Also with FHA, there is a loan limit, check out, you can see them below:

https://fhaloans.guide/loan-li...

Whichever you decide, good luck!

Quote from @Eric S.:

Hi, I live in Toronto, Ontario (Canada) and have $150k in equity in able to access. I would like to start purchasing student rentals which would have a purchase price of around $400k. I'm not able to be approved for a mortgage as my dti will be too high after pulling out equity. I'm considering partnering up with a friend and buying in cash. Would this be the best use of this money? Also, what would be the best form of taking out the equity?

Thanks


 Eric,

Where would you be buying the properties, in Canada or the US? If you are buying in the US you could do a DSCR loan which essentially will take into account the market rent produced by the property. As long as the market rent is determined to be higher than the total mortgage payment you will be good to go (You could also have the mortgage be higher than the rent but the terms will be extremely unfavorable). If the properties you are trying to buy are in Canada, I would not be able to hep answer this for this. Please reach out with any questions.

Quote from @Nicholas Crawford:

The situation

House is rented for $2,200/month. Property is currently in a bridge loan ($2,200/mo). Rehab took much longer than intended for various reasons numbers quit working as interest rates went up. I'm self employed so can't do conventional refinance. Looked into Hard Money refi as I did with another property but the amount out of pocket even with high appraisal was astronomical. Property is in an LLC. Can't co-sign on a refi. Estimated appraisal 350k-400k. But who knows with how the market has been as of late. Need to refi 305k that's in the bridge loan. The main issue is DSCR wont work out so any lender is going to require massive amount at closing to offset or reduce loan amount.

Options considered.

Take the hit on high closing with hard money and offset risk of a worse situation down the road (would basically eliminate all savings)

Extend bridge loan and hope one of the areas at issue improves 

"Sell" to friend/family and pay them 

Cosign on refi (was told cannot by lender) maybe a way around that?

rob bank? jk

Any clever ideas out there? I can't be the first person to have the numbers not work out after a rehab. Any help is greatly appreciated.

Sincerely, Nick 


 Nick,

I agree with the other posters. I would need the address to get exact numbers but at a 305,000 loan amount at 8% you are basically at $2,200 without adding insurance or taxes into the payment. If you were to quitclaim someone onto title, you would have to wait at least 6 months to do the cash out (I believe this rule is being changed to a year in a couple months). You would either have to sell or put more money down. Most DSCR lenders will accept unlimited gift funds so if you have someone who can gift you the money to get the loan amount down, it could work.

Post: Buying student housing using DSCR loan

Matthew WolkPosted
  • Lender
  • Tampa, FL
  • Posts 79
  • Votes 27
Quote from @Bradley Rieger:

Are you able to qualify for a DSCR loan when buying student housing in a college town. You can get more rent from students than if you rented the house as a single family. Will the DSCR lender look at the student housing comps or will they use the single family as there rent comps.


 Bradley,

When you say "student housing" are you talking about off campus single family or multi family homes that house students?  Or are you talking about a huge apartment complex with a ton of units?  The lender will not discriminate against who is living in the subject property.  The appraiser will complete a market rent analysis on the property and as long as the rent is higher than the mortgage payment you are good to go (You could still do the loan if the mortgage payment is higher but the terms will be pretty unfavorable).  If there is a lease in place, you could also use that.  Some lenders will allow the lease to be used even if rent schedule turns out lower if the tenants have been in the house for at least 3 months.  Please reach out with any other questions!

Post: Buying a rental with an FHA but not living in it

Matthew WolkPosted
  • Lender
  • Tampa, FL
  • Posts 79
  • Votes 27
Quote from @Tim Herman:
Quote from @Niraj S.:

Just to add on to the original discussion..what if an investor is buying a duplex using an FHA loan and rents only one side of it and leaves the other side vacant for 1 year. Does that meet the requirements of the FHA loan?

 @Matthew Wolk and @Lyndsay Zwirlein how does this negate the owner occupancy requirements. Vacant does not mean owner occupied.

I misread the initial post.  My apologies for confusion.  I had replied to the thread and said for FHA loan you would have to occupy one of the units.

Post: Buying a rental with an FHA but not living in it

Matthew WolkPosted
  • Lender
  • Tampa, FL
  • Posts 79
  • Votes 27
Quote from @Kenzie McIlvoy:
Quote from @Matthew Wolk:

Yes, that would be fine!

No you would have to live in one of the units.  FHA loan, you MUST live in the house for at least a year. 

Post: Buying a rental with an FHA but not living in it

Matthew WolkPosted
  • Lender
  • Tampa, FL
  • Posts 79
  • Votes 27

Yes, that would be fine!

Post: Buying a rental with an FHA but not living in it

Matthew WolkPosted
  • Lender
  • Tampa, FL
  • Posts 79
  • Votes 27
Quote from @Kenzie McIlvoy:

My husband and I are wrapping up over a year long live in flip at our lake house that we plan to make a STR in the spring. We are under contract to sell our LTR and want to replace it with a second STR. Because we lived in that property over 2 of the last 5 years we don't have to worry about 1031.

We planned on purchasing a property with a DCSR loan but our realtor strongly advised that we do an FHA loan instead. We told him that we do *not* plan on living in this property and we plan on buying another (our dream home) sometime in the spring. He has more than insisted because of low down payment and interest rate, comparatively. We've never heard of using an FHA for a property that's not your primary residence and don't know if this is possible and what the consequences would be. We want to invest the right way but more importantly, we don't want to jeopardize our financing for our primary residence here in a few months. He suggested using a conventional loan in the spring for our primary residence. Our realtor is also on board with this and stating that this happens all the time.

We are on a journey to build our wealth and getting very close to financial freedom but we want to do it the right way. Any thoughts or advice would be so helpful. Thank you!


It is an FHA guideline that you must occupy the house within 60 days and live in it for at least 1 year. So if you do not live in it, you will be committing mortgage fraud.

Quote from @Michael Baum:

Poof! They are gone!


 Bahahaha