i bought a cabin in north Georgia this past February. I live 2.5 hours from there and initally I started out completely on my own, with a local housekeeper that I found from Angie's List. I hired a professional photographer and then listed on VRBO and Airbnb. I was doing really well, with the bulk of my bookings coming from Airbnb.
I decided to give Evolve a try, thinking their marketing would increase my bookings from VRBO, as well as overall bookings.
The pros that I found were their photopraphs are amazing. I thought the first ones I had taken were pretty incredibe but they do some editing and seem to enhance them. Next, the description of my cabin is quite professional and inviiting.
That being said, I miss being the first point of contact with my guests, as well as being able to negotiate with them on any special needs/issues they may have. If I'm able to speak with the guest, I may make an exception; for instance I may allow them to bring a larger dog than the 50 pound size limit that is listed. The personal aspect that people like seems to be lost. Also, you can charge extra fort extra guests when you list on your own. With Evolve, you cannot. It cost more and takes more time for housekeeping to clean when there are extra people.
I can't see that my bookings have increased whatsoever and as a traveler that booked a house through VRBO/Evolve last year, I found the booking process to be a little cumbersome. I booked the house and then received an email telling me to call Evolve, so there were some extra calls and emails that aren't necessary when that middleman isn't there. It was a great house and the owner was a teriffic host, but the booking process was just a little confusing.
Overall, I think it depends on where you are located as to how well you will do using Evolve. They use their case studies to sell you, but all houses/locations aren't going to produce those same results. You also have to weigh how involved you want to be in the day-to-day process. For me, I've found that I really like hosting (not just getting a booking and the money) and most people like to know who their host is and I like to know who my guest is. There will be no pictures or bios like what you see on the other sites.
I would be interested to know what other people think who have used Evolve for their short term rentals.