Hey Michelle,
A couple notes on that...
1. First I understand what they are referring to, but it sounds like they may not understand the dynamics of investment properties and this specific kind of financing. When it comes to investment properties you will have higher rates/fees than a primary residence regardless whether that is conventional or DSCR. In that realm of mortgages, there is a restriction on pricing being compliant, and that is typically 3 points in total that can be charged to a buyer. However right now even the highest rates we can offer you for an investment are still carrying points. However with an investment specifically you could charge 4 points and be alright compliantly depending on the other fees since there are other factors at play.
2. I'm not sure where they might have been looking but 4 points seems a bit high based on what you just mentioned above. I want to make clear when I say for this I am estimating $200,000 price, 20% down and a 740 Credit Score but we would be looking at 3 points right now with that. There may be community lending programs available depending on the location of the property as well. I'm not sure where that broker may have been looking, but I'd encourage you to make sure they understand the dynamics of investment financing and some of those incentives. If it might help to look at those as possible options, feel free to reach out