The space was ok. It was "renovated" in 2008 by us. We had an electrical violation and had to fix that and then we decided to fix it up. So, you had normal VCT tile, some new lighting and a decent bathroom. I would say if you were going to start an office or store, you could just paint it and be set. The store was functional.
We had two real restaurants interested and we actually got into lease negotiations with them but both fell apart. But, they would have fixed up the place on their dime. One guy showed me one of his restaurants and he dropped a lot of money into it. Because my dad bought the building a long time ago, you were looking at improvement budgets that were more than he paid for the place.
I did not see your response before my second post. So, individually metered is good. I agree with what John said. Clean it and make it look good. I had a horrible basement and over the years I cleaned it up and had a guy drylok the walls and painted the floors. People liked it a lot. I did it because I was thinking of renting out the basement as storage. I still might but it had a collateral effect of making the place look better. But, other than slight cosmetic stuff, you shouldn't be paying for jack.
As far as restaurants, I only bring it up because you will get a call from your broker and they might ask you if you are open to a restaurant with a vent. If you aren't fine. Your decision. This coffee shop is only making coffee, drinks and pressed sandwiches. It is not as intrusive as a real restaurant. If someone wanted to open a space with a dry use, you would only have to cover some pipes. I was not too keen on restaurants but the space was sitting there for a while.
I was seeing people wanting to get into ten year leases with five year renewals. So, dropping $100k is not seen as an outrageous expense. They know they have to pay for fix ups.
We are in East Bed Stuy near Broadway. The commercial and residential market is changing daily.
I leaned on my broker a lot and asked him what was commercially reasonable. Same for my lawyer. Helps out a lot having good people. Commercial leases are heavily slanted towards landlords.
Finally, you have to look at the experience of the potential tenant. Do they know what they are doing? How much cash do they have? Does the store make sense for the area? Are they pains to deal with? After these three lease negotiations, I have learned a lot.