@Trent Barga, I don't think this sounds like a bad deal at all if it's in a nice suburb of Dayton. It's easy to jump in and say that you're paying too much, and look at this deal over here that is much cheaper, but then you look at the other deal and see that it's in a much worse area.
I don't doubt your numbers, and if they're true, I think you'll make a nice return on this deal.
BUT, I agree with others in this thread (and it sounds like you agree too) that you will likely be spreading yourself too thin. I don't know how much margin you have right now, but if you buy this deal yourself, you will be an Active investor. Some months may be light, but some months will make you feel like you picked up a part-time job. It doesn't sound like that's what you want.
Have you considered throwing your money into a syndication or a JV with someone who does want to be active?... Someone who invests in RE full-time... Someone who knows more than you about Dayton and it's suburbs? You shouldn't expect the same level of returns obviously, but you should expect far less time commitment and stress... as long as you find a good sponsor/operator!