Maui has grappled with this question for ages and enacted all kinds of laws to restrict short term rentals. Unfortunately most of these laws go unenforced, yet locals still blame the tourists for everything . . . including the housing shortage which is in fact created by OVERREGULATION and restrictive zoning laws. Studies have shown restrictive zoning, in particular related to density, does adversely affect low-income families. https://www.brookings.edu/blog...
I agree that vacationers get a bad rap for "spoiling neighborhoods" and late night parties when in my experience these complaints are equally true of local families, be they homeowners or long-term tenants. I should know. I live down the street from an illegal cockfighting operation, which creates lots of noise and parking problems, and let me assure you there are no tourists involved in that.
Does it bother me? NO. Would I ever dream of turning my neighbor in? NO. Actually I'm kind of proud that this remnant of local culture survives, and aside from the illegal aspect it does fit in with the AG zoning. Bottom line, you can't control what your neighbor does unless you want to live in a Communist society.
We should hold our leaders accountable for this housing shortage, which again on Maui is totally the result of it being so hard to develop, rather than letting them pass it off onto the short term rentals. I can't tell you how many affordable housing projects have been rejected by the County Council who continues to gripe about the housing shortage THEY created. Now their big idea is to phase out the areas already zoned for short-term rental!