i can buy into the "don't submitt under a certain number" theory...makes alot of sense.
but you forgot one big scenario....SOME REALTORS PLAY FAVORITES!!!!
I've offered on properties that eventually sold for less to buyers that i KNOW are submitting with the same contingencies and conditions as i am....i know this because they've told me so. in some of these cases these realtors get to market these same properties on the back end of the deal....double dipping????
they also hold deals for people they're more comfortable dealing with... these are busy people and streamling operations is in their best interest. I know this because i've gotten "into the loop" with a certain few in my area and i feel certain i'm getting some of these deals because they know me, know i answer the phone and know that i do what i say when i say i'll do it....why else would i be getting an reo deal thats priced right yet i didn't even know about it until after it's been listed for several days and they even called ME about it. i'm sure they've had 20 offers before seeing mine and i'm pretty sure mine isn't the highest. why would they be real excited about submitting an offer thats 2k higher than mine from someone they don't know when all it means to them is 2 maybe 3% of the difference which can mean what...50 bucks. why bother
also, if you're breaking into a new market and trying to establish a name for yourself, you can count on at least a few of your offers getting canned. the investor market here is hot with newbies trying to buy reo properties with no proof of funds, little to no earnest and a 45-60 day close with the hopes of assigning the deals because thats what the guru's are telling them to do....thinking not!
on top of that, consider how the agent is forced to submitt the offers to the bank. i know some companies have a very streamlined, internet based system for submitting, simply entering a few of the vital statistics of your offer such as..price, date to close, payment method, contingencies. i'll get answers from them in a matter of hours.
others are in the stone-age and are doing it by scanning the whole contract and addenda or by using a fax! that's a paperwork nightmare which i can assure you leads to the pitching of rookie offers..you may never get a response....
if you don't think you are being taken seriously or aren't getting return calls....ASK FOR A WRITTEN OFFER RESPONSE!