Quote from @Lina Vezzani-Katano:
Hi all, I'm in a conundrum and need smart suggestions.
I currently rent out a 1 family house that is way below market value. The current rent barely pays for the monthly mortgage and I am scraping through to pay for property taxes.
I have two options in mind:
1. Sell the house.
2. Get a loan to fix the basement to bring rent to market value.
I'm sure I would need to provide more information for answers so let me know!
Thanks in advance! - Lina
Hi Lina,
Your situation is very common, and deciding between selling or investing more into your property to potentially increase its income is a pivotal choice. Here are some considerations for both options to help you make a more informed decision:
Option 1: Sell the House
Pros:Immediate liquidity: Selling the house can provide you with a lump sum of money immediately.
Eliminate financial strain: If the property has been a financial burden, selling it could relieve you of the ongoing stress and financial obligations.
Capital gains: Depending on how long you've owned the property and the real estate market conditions, you might realize significant capital gains from the sale.
Cons:Capital Gains Tax: If the property has appreciated in value since you bought it, you could be liable for capital gains tax, which could eat into your profits.
Loss of potential future appreciation: Real estate generally appreciates over time. Selling now means you could miss out on potential future gains.
Market conditions: If the market is currently down, you might not get as much for the property as you would in a stronger market.
Option 2: Get a Loan to Fix the Basement
Pros:Increase property value: Renovating the basement can add significant value to your property, both in terms of rental income and resale value.
Higher rental income: With the basement fixed, you can charge market value rent, which could help cover the mortgage, property taxes, and the cost of the loan, with the profit potential.
Tax deductions: The cost of renovations can often be deducted from your taxes, either through depreciation or as an immediate expense, depending on the nature of the renovation.
Cons:Additional debt: Taking out a loan adds another layer of financial obligation and risk, especially if the increased rent doesn't cover the loan payments.
Renovation risks: Renovations can sometimes uncover more issues that need fixing, leading to cost overruns and delays.
Market risks: There's no guarantee that the market rent will remain high or that you will find tenants willing to pay the increased rent.
Additional Considerations:
Current Market Analysis: Understanding the current real estate market in your area is crucial. Are property values expected to rise? Is there a high demand for rentals?
Cost-Benefit Analysis: Consider conducting a cost-benefit analysis for renovating the basement. Estimate the total cost of the renovation and the expected increase in rental income. Compare this to the potential profit from selling the property now.
Long-term Goals: Consider your long-term financial goals. Are you looking for immediate financial relief or are you in a position to invest more now for potentially greater returns in the future?
Financing Options: Explore different financing options for the renovation. Interest rates, loan terms, and the feasibility of securing a loan with favorable terms should all be considered.
Best of luck with your decisions,
KC