@Mike Lambert
Mike, great discussion! Yes, you make an excellent point about Puerto Rico not being as big of a vacation destination as some of the other areas nearby. I've heard it said that only 7% of Puerto Rico's economy is tourist based. Historically, Puerto Rico focused on pharmaceuticals and never got quite as dependent on tourism as places like Hawaii and some other parts of the Caribbean. That could be seen as a positive or negative. As an US based investor, I find certain comfort in investing in Puerto Rico, which is a US Territory, but obviously since you are comparing your investments to international investments, you may be looking at things that I am not. And while I am not against investing in Mexico, DR or Columbia (I've heard some great things...) there is a sweet spot as an American investing in an area that I don't need a passport to travel to, and that uses the same currency, and feels safer because it's part of the US. But that's not to say that higher return investments don't exist offshore. You have much more experience than I do in international investing.
I do think Puerto Rico should work a bit harder to build its reputation as a travel destination (which is probably why they have created incentives like act 74, which offers tax credits on tourist/hotel type of projects), and they do have other things in the works I've heard are coming. That said, there are tons of tourists here. Lots of folks from the east coast of US. And the cruise ships aren't even running right now. But there are loads of tourists here, I see them all day long. In fact, the busiest flight path in world is is between Orlando and San Juan, PR. (as reported 5 days ago News.com.au) https://www.news.com.au/travel...
As for tax incentives, you are absolutely right that they should not drive the decision but be a bonus if the deal works. That's spot on. I work with many investors like myself who have US tax liability - knowing I can create an act 74 project in PR where 30% of my investment is given back in tax credits makes it extremely desirable for someone like me, since running short term rentals is something I was doing for over 12 years in California with no tax benefit. Why not own short term rentals in beautiful Puerto Rico and get a tax advantage to boot? So for me it's comfortable and it's close. That might not work for everyone.