@Shane Willis what a great problem to have. I don’t know enough information about your particular market or strategy to offer sound advice. But the two things that I think I would consider are:
1. What is your market doing with regards to appreciation, and rent rates. I know nationally rents are rising fast, so that few hundred bucks you mentioned might be double that in a few short years. As well, you may see significant appreciation in the asset itself.
2. To wholesale it, I would be thinking about how much turn over is in your current market and are you going to keep flipping and or wholesaling properties? If that is a method that you’ve got figured out in your market and you’re willing to keep rolling those proceeds into more and more deals, there is a good chance you can make more money over the long run.
I think looking at national trends option one sounds most appealing to me, but again, I don’t know your market or strategy.
Best of luck with your awesome problem.