I like how local players will more or less share what we're doing on here :)
After wasting lots of money on marketing over the last two years, and hopefully only now moving closer to something that is working, here are a few additional general conclusions:
1. People are flooded with mail. You have to do something different or you're unlikely to get ANY traction.
As an example, we sent 2600 postcards last month, with a typical investor postcard mail house type design, and got... wait for it, 4 calls. (I'm still suspicious that the mail house actually sent them but we got some returns and they did verify that it went out, so I don't know...).
53218, for example, gets hammered with mail. Literally, from colleagues and property managers I know they'll get ten postcards on the same house, sometimes in a week. (As a side note, another mailer must've forgotten to de-dupe the addressee on his likely free and clear mailing list and sent a friend of mine 25 postcards on one mailing, lol).
2. Consistency is difficult but key. That's why there's wisdom in outsourcing the mailers, or, like we are doing now, designing your whole campaign on the front end (say 5 cards or whatever you decide) and placing them on the schedule. Once you get bogged down chasing leads and talking to unmotivated sellers you can have trouble getting your next mailing out, and that hurts your whole project.
3. Real estate is a really slow burn. Coincidentally (to me writing this post at this moment), tomorrow I have a listing that closes - I mailed as a buyer but give options - that I mailed on my first ever probate mailing 2.5 years ago. Yeah, that slow even.
4. FOLLOW UP. As we're starting to see now (and as every marketing expert emphasizes) you will close more on follow up than the initial contact. I met with a seller in early November, gave him an offer (he didn't take it) and then we went our way. I called him about ten days ago and, coincidentally, his nephew's flailing attempt to buy the property had just died, and he wanted to have me come back out. We close next Friday to a wholesale buyer.
But, prioritizing follow up can be hard to do, especially when you get busy. We're still figuring out a better system for this, and thanks to Brew City I think we actually have one.
That's it I guess. And FWIW, @Alex Witte, I think of you and @Daniel Hanson as buyers for flips, so hoping I get one for you soon. I told Dan about the last offer I put in out there but I ended up getting beat by another member of Brew City. What'd he do with it? Cleaned it out, put it on the MLS, sold for 75k profit... I know...
What else you buying? Shoot me an email if you want.
And @Marcus Auerbach, I'd say something like 95% of my efforts are in this world but 95% of my income is from the MLS, lol, so you might have a better strategy at the moment.