Quote from @Brent T Howell:
Hello Jon,
I know this post is older but I am curious about how your two homes have turned out as rentals? In my market it sound a lot like yours in that it is a solid blue collar neighborhood that has homes from around the 40-60's. 2 bed 1 bath 650-800 sqft. I could scoop them for a good price, fix and rent them for a good turn.
I would love to hear back. I am really thinking about pulling the trigger on a couple of these things.
Brent
So far so good. The first one is going through it’s first turnover as we speak. A young family with one child lived there and they were good tenants. After a Few thousand in paint and other things it will be rented for $1025. That’s up from $775 just 2 years ago.
The second one is in a rougher neighborhood and the first tenant wasn't that great, but luckily didn't do much damage and didn't renew. We now have a tenant that's a better fit for the property. He's a disabled veteran and his rent is covered 100% by section 8 and the VA. He's paying $884 up from $750 2 years ago. It looks like he's happy and will stay awhile. It's all about matching the right tenant to the right property.