Downdraft stoves gone out of style?

[John Collins]

Need a new stove put in.

The existing system is downdraft but I don't see anything decent below $1400 and options are limited. I know they are less efficient than the overhead fans but this house was installed with one a couple decades ago.

For going with a range hood, the cost is $200, installation is $500... which is fine, but ductwork will have to be put in and creatively. The ceiling above just is a no go zone from 3 different contractors and I've looked around with a flashlight myself. It has to be done over the island (island range hood) as otherwise we have to tear out cabinets/sink adding more work. The quotes average around $1800. So with a new stove, it's $3k. 

Is the extra $1600 worth it , or is a downdraft good enough?