So, I can't say for sure that my plan works because I'm still in the process right now, but I've been prepping a For Sale By Owner for a future low ball offer. I've told them that I'm an investor and I can't pay what a regular homeowner can pay or I wouldn't make any money. I also told them that there isn't a right or wrong answer, but they have to decide if they want to wait for a homeowner who can offer more or if they just want to be free of the house and if we can do it, I will do my best with an offer, but it won't be what they are asking.
I twice told them "no offense, but the house isn't in very good shape" and I also told them they were asking over what the county says it's value is. (I'm trying to help them see that their asking price isn't realistic.) I told them I'm trying to help them and am asking other investor friends to take a look at the property too, in case one of them wants it because I want what is best for the house and the neighborhood. The house is boarded up and I told them that isn't good for anyone, so I'm doing what I can to help.
I've told them it's a seller's market right now and most houses in our area are being sold between 1 wk and 1 month after going on the market, so if this house has been for sale longer than that (it has) and he hasn't had any offers (given the condition and location, I'm assuming not--I'm looking to use it for Section 8), he should really consider an investor's offer.
I also told him that, no offense, but most homeowners wouldn't be interested in the house because most homeowners want a nicer house, even if they end up trashing it later. I told him that if he sells to an investor, they will rent it out and will then have to take good care of the house to keep it rented. (Or at least in theory they will.)
He hasn't paid his taxes yet. (I suspect it's an inherited house.) I plan to look at the house inside in person (I'm out-of-state) next week and will tell him about the taxes, whether I decide to offer or not. If I decide to offer, I'll tell him about the taxes and that I'll pay them if we can get into a contract before the end of the year.
I'm trying to slowly let him see that his offer isn't realistic and that I want what's best and am not just out to gouge him. When it comes time to offer, I'll list all the things that need fixing and how much it will cost so he knows I'm not just making up offers. But since the county says the house is only worth $22k (he wants $25k), it won't be long before I'll reach that in repairs if the inside looks like the outside. If I need to, I'm not beneath offering him $1 just to get it off his hands. But I'm hoping not to go below $5500 because that's what the land is worth, so it only seems fair that he should get at least that. We will see...
Oh, and I'm keeping him up to date about other people's interest levels, so he knows I'm honestly trying to sell his house. I told him I don't care if it's me that buys it, but I want someone to because it's what's best for the house and the neighborhood. But whenever someone says they aren't interested, I use that opportunity to gently remind him of what he's up against in selling this house. ;-)