Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Jason Malabute

Jason Malabute has started 543 posts and replied 1391 times.

Post: CALCULATING ARV ADJUSTMENTS

Jason MalabutePosted
  • Accountant
  • Los Angeles, CA
  • Posts 1,413
  • Votes 660
Originally posted by @Brian Pulaski:

@Jason Malabute I described above, the calculation I have seen used for lot size is $3000/acre. A 1 acre lot would be $3000 less ARV than a 2 acre, etc.

In my area improvements are listed on the Assessors site, giving the SF size.

 Thank you. Last question, how would. you calculate adjustments for factors that are less tangible like the age or condition of the property while being "conservative " as you said above? That one of problems I was having was my realtor couldn't find comps in same age, condition, and neighborhood because it was a multiunit.  

Post: CALCULATING ARV ADJUSTMENTS

Jason MalabutePosted
  • Accountant
  • Los Angeles, CA
  • Posts 1,413
  • Votes 660
Originally posted by @Brian Pulaski:

@Jason Malabute I am in a new market, however when i bought my current house, I got a copy of the appraisal. The values he used up/down almost mirrored my last market (central CT), so I simply used what I "knew".

As far as a patio, if my house didn't have one, but a comparable house had a 200 SF one, then I would adjust by 200 SF x $10/SF or $2000. It is not by any means that this is exact, however it helps me get an idea, as well as gets me solid comparables for the day an actual appraisal happens.

Regarding living verse total SF, I feel weird saying this, but what do you mean total SF? If a house is a 1000 SF ranch with a full unfinished basement, I compare it as a 1000 SF house. If it has a 500 SF section of the basement finished, I treat that area as the appraisers did, which was a reduced $/SF amount. What other SF would be included in the total?

Sorry for the confusion. By "total SF" I meant lot size. So when calculating $/ per SF or ARV do you use/compare the "living SF" or lot size?

Also how did you know the SF of patio? Did you just. ask? 

Thanks. 

Post: CALCULATING ARV ADJUSTMENTS

Jason MalabutePosted
  • Accountant
  • Los Angeles, CA
  • Posts 1,413
  • Votes 660
Originally posted by @Brian Pulaski:

@Jason Malabute this is all part of the "art" of running comps and getting your ARV. Lately I have been treating them like an appraisal. I have a few appraisals in my folders and use the adjustments they used. $30/SF for main living space. $10/SF for decks/patios and basement living space. $3000/acre. I don't know that this is the best way, however I have seen it compared with realtor CMAs and my numbers are usually right where those come in. I do my best to get houses in the same area, similar style, similar age, and if possible only use renovated houses. If there is anything that's tough to adjust (exact location) i am just conservative.

I found this. video on youtube on how to do CMA. Is this what you are talking about?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pq0at1xPVdE

Post: CALCULATING ARV ADJUSTMENTS

Jason MalabutePosted
  • Accountant
  • Los Angeles, CA
  • Posts 1,413
  • Votes 660
Originally posted by @Brian Pulaski:

@Jason Malabute this is all part of the "art" of running comps and getting your ARV. Lately I have been treating them like an appraisal. I have a few appraisals in my folders and use the adjustments they used. $30/SF for main living space. $10/SF for decks/patios and basement living space. $3000/acre. I don't know that this is the best way, however I have seen it compared with realtor CMAs and my numbers are usually right where those come in. I do my best to get houses in the same area, similar style, similar age, and if possible only use renovated houses. If there is anything that's tough to adjust (exact location) i am just conservative.

 Thank you. How would you get those appraisal amounts in a new market? Would you just divide the value of the patio by the square foot?

I also noticed that you used the living square foot and not the total square foot. Do you consider the total square foot when calculating ARV?

Post: CALCULATING ARV ADJUSTMENTS

Jason MalabutePosted
  • Accountant
  • Los Angeles, CA
  • Posts 1,413
  • Votes 660

Is there video I can watch of how to calculate ARV adjustments for any market?

Ive been having hard time figuring out by how much to adjust the comps up or down.

Does anyone have a step by step guide how to calculate ARV adjustment?

For example if the comp had an extra bedroom how would you calculate to adjust ARV down?

Or if the comp is built a decade earlier, or is in better condition, or is on better school district how would you determine the adjustment amount?

Thanks!

Post: How to accurately make adjustments to comparables to determine ARV

Jason MalabutePosted
  • Accountant
  • Los Angeles, CA
  • Posts 1,413
  • Votes 660
However, what is the judgement call based on? In other words, what are the standards and steps in develop. the adjustment. amounts in any market?Thank. you.

Originally posted by @Han Oh:

@Scott R. thanks for the article. I agree that accurately calculating adjustments is a judgment call based on the individual market, and that's why I think I need to get a whole lot of practice and experience to become good at it. 

@Joe Homs thanks for the feedback. Yes, the listing price seemed a little too good to be true but then it's a short sale so depends on what the bank is willing to accept. The agent told me that the short sale was accepted by the bank and went into a binding contract with some buyer (although she didn't sound 100% sure) so no more showings. I'll have to find a vacant home like you say to crunch some real numbers..

Post: Investor with a disability

Jason MalabutePosted
  • Accountant
  • Los Angeles, CA
  • Posts 1,413
  • Votes 660
Thank you and happy holidays!

Originally posted by @Stephanie D.:

@Jason Malabute I applaud you for not letting your disability hinder your goals!  Just remember everyone has strengths and weaknesses, capitalize on your strengths.  I used to hate presenting in college; I'm an introvert and much rather not have everyone's eyes on me while I'm talking.  One day though, I had a break through: familiarizing myself with the material I was presenting to a point where I knew the subject thoroughly.  Every time I presented, I aimed to be the authority on the subject so that I didn't stumble over my own words and no questions would catch me off guard.  It got to the point where I actually enjoyed giving presentations!  Think this could be key for you.  I believe if you study and practice cold calling (with people you know), you will be able to overcome your speech impediment because you become comfortable with the subject and how you run your business.  

Wishing you all the best!  Please keep us posted regarding your progress.  I'm inspired by your determination to go after your goals and am sure others in this community will be just as inspired and find themselves cheering for you from their computers.

Post: Investor with a disability

Jason MalabutePosted
  • Accountant
  • Los Angeles, CA
  • Posts 1,413
  • Votes 660
Thank you can you send me the scripts please? After a couple of weeks of practicing the scripts can I practice them on you over the phone for feedback? Thank you again for helping me.

Originally posted by @Ray Lai:
Originally posted by @Jason Malabute:
Originally posted by @Ray Lai:

@Jason Malabute

Negative, would not use a call center because skill in listening for distress and motivation while building rapport with sellers and helping them solve problems by communicating key information is crucial and greatly amps up your conversion rate so I wouldn't outsource this function personally. 

Do you have anyone you personally know that has the time to answer calls and would be part of your team starting off? Going to a call-center from the get-go is outsourcing a vital function without doing in-house first. Makes sense if you know what you're doing and have scaled up but your condition sounds difficult to talk to sellers so creative thinking may be in order? 

Also, I'm a big advocate of bootstrapping when you start off and keeping costs low and then outsourcing low value added activities first, not the high value ones that you should spend your attention on.

 Nobody really comes to my head. My mom is to scared to call people and would want to d o things her way. Should I try calling myself even with speech impediment ?

This is a tough one because I don't know anyone with your condition. What I can say is that I can send you all the best scripts I have and you can take a look at them and ask me any questions you want and I'm happy to help you. Then you can decide whether you are up for trying to talk to people / practice (call some Craigslist ads). If you can't do it but learn how to do it, you may be able to train someone you trust to do it on your behalf. Or you can leave this part of the supply chain and work on something like rehabing and picking up deals from a solid wholesaler or other means. Up to you many options. It's good to play to our strengths and acknowledge our own weaknesses. Shoot me a msg if you want scripts and any help.

Post: Investor with a disability

Jason MalabutePosted
  • Accountant
  • Los Angeles, CA
  • Posts 1,413
  • Votes 660
Originally posted by @Ray Lai:

@Jason Malabute

Negative, would not use a call center because skill in listening for distress and motivation while building rapport with sellers and helping them solve problems by communicating key information is crucial and greatly amps up your conversion rate so I wouldn't outsource this function personally. 

Do you have anyone you personally know that has the time to answer calls and would be part of your team starting off? Going to a call-center from the get-go is outsourcing a vital function without doing in-house first. Makes sense if you know what you're doing and have scaled up but your condition sounds difficult to talk to sellers so creative thinking may be in order? 

Also, I'm a big advocate of bootstrapping when you start off and keeping costs low and then outsourcing low value added activities first, not the high value ones that you should spend your attention on.

 Nobody really comes to my head. My mom is to scared to call people and would want to d o things her way. Should I try calling myself even with speech impediment ?

Post: Investor with a disability

Jason MalabutePosted
  • Accountant
  • Los Angeles, CA
  • Posts 1,413
  • Votes 660
Originally posted by @James C.:

Jason,

It isn't reasonable for your agent to call on your behalf. 

My suggestion is to have someone cold call for you, and take your calls. That way, you have some time to write down what you want to say when you call them back, and you are in control of the conversation. 

Hope that helps.

Good Luck!

 Thank you. Are you suggesting I use a call center like the person below is??