Originally posted by @Marc Winter:
While gas heat is usually less expensive for the tenant to run, it is A LOT more expensive for the owner to maintain. If you are talking about a 150k btu boiler or hydronic system, you are looking at $100+ minimum each heating season. Count on cleaning, chimney inspection, filter changes. If there is an internal problem like a gas valve, rusted heat riser, bad circulator pump or (gasp) a cracked boiler, you better buckle up.
When we have a situation where an owner we represent has to put in major money in repairs or must replace a regular gas boiler, we always examine the possibility of installing electric baseboard heating. We RARELY have a tenant leave because of the heat, because you can/should adjust the asking rent to allow for the extra expense.
That being said, we have purchased dozens of long-term buy/holds with electric heat. We found no more trouble to find tenants, but a LOT fewer maintenance issues. Good luck in your hunt.
Marc,
I noted you are from PA which will serve as a good comparison as that is where I am as well. I am on board with this thought process and have currently been evaluating heating on a rental unit I purchased and I am currently doing a 100% "gut" renovation on.
Its a SFR that has a forced air oil furnace. The unit is unknown if it works and as well I have no current assessment of the 275 gal tanks although my gut feeling is the tanks are fine. The main issue with this is the chimney was in disrepair and needed torn down (i.e. well it has been torn down). Our options are
1. $2500 for furnace repair and installation of a double wall flue pipe.
2. $3500 for electric furnace (i.e. not heat pump)
3. $6000 to run gas pipe and install gas furnace
I saw you were suggesting baseboard heaters would you recommend these over a electric forced air furnace and do you have any experience with electric forced air furnaces. We were leaning towards trying to find some electric solution to avoid the pitfall of having the tenant manage the oil delivery/payment. Gas is really not a desired option just because the cost. Would love any insight you have. Our biggest fear was the bill being so high that we struggle to keep tenants.