Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 54%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$69 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Ian Tyndall

Ian Tyndall has started 15 posts and replied 128 times.

I don't know your sources of information but they are generally mot accurate. There are conditions to qualify for the STR REPs status that are unique to the STR business.

Some conditions that you have to document and be able to prove:

1. You must spend at least 100 hours managing guests and more time than anyone else in the calendar year

2. Average length of stay must be less than 7 days

Post: How to find STRs on sale?

Ian TyndallPosted
  • Investor
  • Glen Allen, VA
  • Posts 131
  • Votes 120

If you are looking on Zillow, try the terms:

Airbnb, furnished, STR, short term rental, No HOA, furnished, rental history


Those terms usually bring up existing STR properties. If you look through the photos and see bathroom sets with fancy soaps and coffee bars, then you know you found one!

Post: Want to collaborate on building a STR GPT?

Ian TyndallPosted
  • Investor
  • Glen Allen, VA
  • Posts 131
  • Votes 120

Here is what I uploaded, and this is my conversation:

STR Property Optimizer

Based on the screenshot provided of your Airbnb listing's pricing settings for September 2023, here are the descriptive statistics:

  • The base price per night is set at $209.
  • Custom weekend price is $240.
  • The majority of the days are priced at $130, which is significantly lower than the base price.
  • Prices increase in the second half of the month, peaking at $325 for the 27th.
  • The weekly discount is 15%, with a weekly average of $1,296.
  • The monthly discount is 21%, with a monthly average of $5,149.
  • There is a notable booking from the 19th to the 26th totaling $1,775.10.

Before proceeding, would you like to adjust any of these pricing settings or is there any other information you wish to update or add? Additionally, could you please provide turnover cost information such as consumables, cleaning fees, laundry expenses, wear and tear, and minor breakage costs? This information will be essential to optimize your revenue taking into account the profitability offset by turnovers.


I told it turnovers total cost is $75 -


Youuse that amount for all costs of a turnover

STR Property Optimizer

Great, we will proceed with a total turnover cost of $75, which encompasses consumables, cleaning, laundry, wear and tear, and minor breakage costs.

Now, let's analyze your current booking data and turnover costs to optimize your pricing strategy:

  1. Turnover Analysis: With a turnover cost of $75, it's vital to balance the frequency of bookings with the associated costs. Shorter stays may increase turnover costs relative to revenue, so we might consider encouraging longer bookings through discounts or minimum stay requirements.
  2. Pricing Adjustments: Your current lowest price is $130, which is well below the base price of $209. Given the turnover cost, it may be beneficial to increase the lower end of your pricing on less popular days to ensure profitability after turnover costs are accounted for.
  3. Discounts: You're offering a 15% weekly discount and a 21% monthly discount. Given the turnover cost savings with longer stays, these discounts can be very attractive, but we should ensure they are set at levels that maximize occupancy without sacrificing profitability.
  4. Seasonal Trends: Review the pricing for the second half of September, which shows a significant increase. Consider local events, holidays, or seasonal demand to ensure these prices are competitive and reflect the value of the stay during these periods.
  5. Occupancy Optimization: Aim to minimize unbooked days, especially consecutive unbooked days that do not save on turnover costs. This may involve dynamic pricing strategies to attract last-minute bookings.

Youwhat should my discounts be?

STR Property Optimizer

Determining the optimal discount rates involves considering the balance between attracting guests with competitive pricing and maintaining profitability. Given your turnover cost of $75, which we are assuming applies to all aspects of preparing your rental for the next guests, here are some considerations for setting your weekly and monthly discounts:

  1. Break-Even Analysis:
    • You need to ensure that the discounted price covers your costs. For example, if your average nightly rate is $209 and you have a $75 turnover cost, the weekly rate without discounts for 7 nights would be $1,463. To break even on a weekly rental after a single turnover, you would need to charge at least $1,538.
  2. Competitor Benchmarking:
    • Research what discounts competitors in your area are offering for similar properties. If they are offering a 10% weekly discount and a 20% monthly discount, you would need to consider whether you can offer a better value or if you need to match these rates.
  3. Occupancy Goals:
    • If your occupancy is high and you're rarely experiencing unbooked days, you might not need to offer large discounts. Conversely, if you have many unbooked days, especially during the week, a higher weekly discount might make sense to incentivize longer stays.
  4. Seasonal Demand Fluctuations:
    • During peak seasons, you may not need to offer large discounts due to higher demand. During off-peak times, higher discounts might be necessary to maintain occupancy.

With these factors in mind, here's a suggested approach:

  • Weekly Discount: Since longer stays save you from incurring multiple turnover costs within a week, you could potentially offer a discount that's enticing but still profitable. Considering a break-even point and the potential for saving on turnover costs, a discount range of 10-20% could be appropriate.
  • Monthly Discount: Longer stays are even more beneficial in terms of reducing turnover frequency. Therefore, a discount of 15-25% could be justifiable, depending on the typical length of stay for guests in your area and your desired occupancy rates.

Post: Want to collaborate on building a STR GPT?

Ian TyndallPosted
  • Investor
  • Glen Allen, VA
  • Posts 131
  • Votes 120

No, not yet. I could set it up where you insert the links of competitors and have it check on them and make recommendations. 

The way it is currently configured is for one specific use case I am working on which is “what is the best weekly and monthly discount that maximizes revenue?”

I will upload my results so you can see

Post: Want to collaborate on building a STR GPT?

Ian TyndallPosted
  • Investor
  • Glen Allen, VA
  • Posts 131
  • Votes 120

Hello world!

This week OpenAI announced the launch of its custom GPT functionality. I started one to help STR hosts (free to use):

ChatGPT - STR Property Optimizer (openai.com)

The focus is on discount pricing strategies right now.  I have trained it to take a screenshot of your Airbnb calendar by property and upload it to the GPT.  Then follow along and see what happens

If you are interested, please take a look and share your feedback with me.  I will continue to add constraints and information to refine the model so that it offers the best advice possible.

https://downpayments.com/

Interesting new company launched today that lends against investment property. Think of it as a HELOC for your investment properties.

I came across it from this article:

https://techcrunch.com/2024/01/10/downpayments-wants-to-offe...

Quote from @Jeff E.:
Quote from @Ian Tyndall:

The new rules require STRs to be permitted as well and pay an annual fee of $250. Has anyone had experience with this new process?

I went through the process with a single family home.  Had about 10 letters to certify mail to neighbors and neighborhood associations in the area.  Took me about 3hrs to do all the paperwork and apply online.  I received my permit about a week later.  I would say it was a little more entailed than other cities such as Scottsdale and Sedona where I have gone through the process also.
That isn’t too bad. Can you share what you put in your letter to your neighbors?  This might be good standard practice even when it isn’t a regulatory requirement. 

The new rules require STRs to be permitted as well and pay an annual fee of $250. Has anyone had experience with this new process?

Post: Minut Referral Codes

Ian TyndallPosted
  • Investor
  • Glen Allen, VA
  • Posts 131
  • Votes 120

All,

I am going to try the Minut noise detection system in one of my properties for indoor & outdoor monitoring.  Does anyone have a referral code that they would like me to use when I place my order?

Post: Questions about short term rentals

Ian TyndallPosted
  • Investor
  • Glen Allen, VA
  • Posts 131
  • Votes 120

Bo,

I am happy to talk. What time zone are you in?