Originally posted by @Jessica Hinman:
Thanks for everyone's speedy replies. After seeing the kind of a damage a daycare did to this property before we bought it, I'm definitely not interested in having our tenants run one. I'm guessing an eviction is the way to go, which really sucks since this is our first tenant in our first property, and he's only been renting for a couple of months!
I've got a $1000 security deposit from the tenant, he has money and so does the daycare he's working for. At this point I'm considering just contacting a lawyer and letting them take over. Do you think I'll be able to cover lawyer's fees with the security deposit and/or suing for damages? Or do you think an eviction is an easy enough process that I can file it on my own? I talked to a friend who's managed properties and he's worried that since this isn't your typical eviction for not paying rent that it might be a bit more complicated.
Hi Jessica: Your friend is right in saying this wouldn't be a typical eviction for non-payment of rent. You need to check out your state laws as they vary widely, and it would probably be wise to run it by an attorney as well; it shouldn't cost too much just for a consultation and could save you more money in the long run. Even if it turns out that you can't evict him, I would be ready with a 30 or 60 day notice (probably 60 just to be on the safe side but check your laws about that also) so that he has to move out at the end of his lease. Beyond voicing your displeasure at his having lied to you, I wouldn't even give him a heads-up on this; just gather as much information on him as possible in anticipation of a lawsuit down the road.
Sorry this is happening to you...baptism by fire, as they say. Try not to be discouraged; there are good tenants out there and you will have more positive experiences than negative. All the best!