Hi @Ben Kirchner
Thanks for starting this post - I appreciate the chance to see what's working for everyone else! I don't know how much work you want to put into it, but I'm closing on a property here in 2 weeks that should bring in just over 1% in Chapel Hill. I found the property by checking Zillow, FSBO, etc every morning and looking at what new properties are listed. I've been doing this for roughly 2 months now, and have had several offers turned down, not accepted, or that I've backed out of after inspection. I specifically look to invest in Charlottesville VA, San Antonio TX, and Raleigh-Durham-Chapel Hill areas.
In this case, I saw the listing at 9:00 on Zillow in Chapel Hill, ran the numbers, called the owner and scheduled a tour, liked what I saw, and made an offer in the same day. It's worth noting, I think, that my offer is using traditional financing (conventional loan). I have alerts set up and spend about 10 minutes each morning looking at what new properties are available (if any) that meet my criteria. I'm aware of 2 other investors in Chapel Hill/Carrboro who have used the same approach: 1 acquired a property in Carrboro and is currently using it as a STR, and the other is a 'traditional' long term rental.
The property I'll soon be closing on is a townhouse - for sale by owner - located on two buslines near UNC and walking distance from downtown Carrboro. The owner is currently renting the downstairs efficiency 1bd/ba for $750. We'll be allowing the tenant to stay for the first year, perhaps 2, and then do some renovations downstairs and up the rent to market value - at somewhere between 900-1000. I'm purchasing the house for $241,000 and will put about 12K into it to do some cosmetic updates, upstairs. I'll then rent out the upstairs 3bd/ba for $1600-$1800, based on what other townhomes on the same street are renting for now. So, it should bring in somewhere around $2350-$2550 per month for the first year, depending on the final rent for the upstairs unit, and more down the road when I update downstairs. Again - I'm scheduled to close in two weeks, and everything seems to be on track so I'm sharing but I also recognize that nothing is set until the lease is signed. I did like seeing the news that students will be back in person this Fall at UNC, although I'm hoping to get another graduate student(s) in, similar to the downstairs tenant.
I'm not sure if you regularly check the various housing sites or rely on your realtor (I, too, have realtors send me regular MLS updates) - and I'm not sure if the strategy I used would really help fill the pipeline you're looking for - but it worked for me. My other rental property is in Charlottesville VA. I've made several offers in San Antonio, but haven't been able to get one accepted their yet.