Originally posted by @Michael Williams:
I think the main issue is that this was a "professional" with all the tools and training that others in the same business posses.
Those that get upset about my not having done more DD in order to verify the agents overestimation is testament to the fact that there are abuses on a regular basis.
Reread, reread.
Best guesses should be left to clairvoyants and charlatans. When one consults a "professional" it's for their expertise. I guess RE agents aren't really worth dealing with if the investors have to "verify" a best guess. Does this mean we really don't need agents at all? Seems that way if we read those who say we need to check the value for accuracy or "buyer beware".
That is correct! Many may heap the entire blame on you and barely look the direction of the Realtor and the cruel fact is that you may have indeed been a victim of fraud.
An investor isn't necessarily an appraiser nor is the Realtor's conduct acceptable just because you were an investor. Investor or not, it helps to verify information of this sort but people do rely on a Realtor's judgment of value to make a buying decision -- which appears to be what you did here.
If the Realtor's estimated ARV is/was grossly inflated, they may have some explaining to do but only if you were to start asking some questions.
Its not whether or not you can sue. Folks have been sued for less than $30K in a real estate or other business transaction. Also, the problem with just dismissing issues of this sort and counting it as "another experience" is that others may also have been defrauded by this person or the firm he or she works for.
As a business or "professional", they may have insurance policies in place which may help lessen your loss and also give them an incentive to provide better information to the public. For what you got, $30K might have been an overpayment of sorts regardless of the lesson.
These are some interesting cases/issues:
http://www.nytimes.com/2008/01/22/business/22agent...
http://aboutfloridalaw.com/2014/07/15/discovering-...